The Sacred Slope
Where the slippery slope becomes sacred ground.
For the spiritually tender — those searching for healthier expressions of our global Christian faith and deconstructing harmful theology.
Listen to conversations with pastors, priests, reverends, scholars, artists, and public voices from multiple denominations, cultures, backgrounds, and genders.
Come to be challenged, healed, and begin again.
The Sacred Slope
64. Healing After Evangelicalism & Finding a Beautiful Faith | Diana Butler Bass (Methodist → Evangelical → Episcopal)
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
64. Healing After Evangelicalism & Finding a Beautiful Faith | Diana Butler Bass (Methodist → Evangelical → Episcopal)
What if the Christianity you were taught was never the only Christianity that existed?
What if leaving evangelicalism didn't mean leaving Jesus?
And what if the people best positioned to help heal Christianity are those who understand more than one Christian world?
Dr. Diana Butler Bass, historian, theologian, and bestselling author, joins Alexis Rice for a conversation about religious trauma, deconstruction, Christian nationalism, and finding beauty and belonging beyond evangelical fundamentalism.
Diana shares her journey from a Methodist childhood through evangelicalism and into the Episcopal Church. Together, they explore the theological diversity many Christians never knew existed and why mainline churches can offer an alternative to the faith systems people are leaving.
At the heart of this conversation is the urgent need for TRANSLATORS.
People who understand evangelical culture AND mainline Christianity. People who can explain evangelical beliefs, fears, and wounds to progressive Christians, pastors, and scholars, while helping those leaving high-control religion discover other ways of following Jesus.
WHO IS THIS EPISODE FOR?
For evangelicals in distress and exvangelicals seeking healing.
For cradle mainliners and progressive Christians who want to understand the evangelical world.
For people of any faith or none who are carrying religious wounds and longing for hope.
And especially for seminarians, scholars, pastors, bishops, and church leaders who want to welcome people shaped by religious trauma and learn from those who can translate between Christian traditions.
Diana reminds us:
"Mainline theology is not a Jenga Tower. Mainline theology is a mosaic."
We also explore her new book, A Beautiful Year: 52 Meditations on Faith, Wisdom, and Perseverance, the Christian calendar, and the beauty of quiet faith.
There are other ways to follow Jesus. There is still beauty to be found.
✨ GUEST + BOOKS
Diana Butler Bass | @dianabutlerbass
A Beautiful Year bookshop.org/shop/thesacredslope
The Cottage | dianabutlerbass.substack.com
⛪ EXPLORE MAINLINE CHRISTIANITY
Episcopal Church | @theepiscopalchurch
United Methodist Church | @theumc
United Church of Christ | @unitedchurchofchrist
ELCA Lutheran | @elca
Presbyterian Church (USA) | @pcusa
Disciples of Christ | @disciplesofchrist
🎙️ PEOPLE + COMMUNITIES
Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde | @mariannbudde
Kristin Kobes Du Mez | @kkdumez
Jemar Tisby | @jemartisby
Robert P. Jones | @robertpjonesdc
Theology Beer Camp | @theologybeercamp
Tripp Fuller | @trippfuller
Dr Jennifer Garcia Bashaw | @jgbashaw
Homebrewed Christianity | @theologynerd
Bible for Normal People | @biblefornormalpeople
Pete Enns | @peteenns
Jared Byas | @jaredbyas
Brian McLaren | @brian_mclaren
Sarah Bessey | @sarahbessey
Jen Hatmaker | @jenhatmaker
Nadia Bolz-Weber | @sarcasticlutheran
Barbara Brown Taylor | @barbarabrowntaylor
Rachel Held Evans (1981-2019) | @rachelheldevans
⏱️ CHAPTERS
03:51 | Meet Diana Butler Bass
11:48 | Methodist to Evangelical
14:46 | Taking Jesus With You
23:21 | Why Christianity Needs Translators
28:54 | Evangelical vs. Mainline
33:43 | Finding a New Church Home
39:48 | Translating Religious Trauma
45:59 | Why Young Adults Leave
52:13 | Jesus, Politics & No Kings
58:02 | Jenga Towers vs. Mosaics
01:03:53 | Deception & Responsibility
01:06:19 | Healing After Evangelicalism
01:10:01 | The Beauty of Quiet Faith
01:14:20 | Empathy & Shared Grief
01:17:36 | A Beautiful Year
01:22:48 | Opening Our Minds
01:36:48 | The Sacred Slope Community
#DianaButlerBass #ABeautifulYear #Deconstruction #ReligiousTrauma #MainlineChristianity
About The Sacred Slope
thesacredslope.com
Where the slippery slope becomes sacred ground.
For the spiritually tender - raised in or rooted in Christianity.
Come explore our global, diverse, inclusive Christian faith, deconstruction, and spiritual identity in a rapidly changing world. Through conversations with clergy, scholars, and cultural voices, the show creates space for people navigating faith after certainty, church harm, or political co-option of religion.
🎧 WATCH: YouTube / Spotify
LISTEN: Apple Podcasts + everywhere
FOLLOW: @thesacredslope (IG, FB, Threads, TikTok, YouTube, Bluesky)
🔗 Connect
🎧 Explore episodes & community: linktr.ee/TheSacredSlope
🎙 Hosted by Alexis Rice
🎵 Music by Brett Rutledge, Eddie Irvin & Sean Spence
📬 Nominate a guest: alexis@thesacredslope.com
🌿 Community Guidelines 🌿
Fruit of the Spirit: ❤️ love • 💫 joy • ☮️ peace • 🕊 patience • 💝 kindness • 🌿 goodness • 🙏 faithfulness • 🤲 gentleness • 💪 self-control
What you learned was actually intellectually consistent internally. And so when like evangelicals, I remember they used to say, well, if you pull out just sort of one piece of it, it's like a Jenga tower. And if you pull out one piece of it, the whole thing falls. That's exactly right. And this is my good news for evangelicals who are listening to us. Mainline theology is not a Jenga tower. Mainline theology is a mosaic. And that means you can lose a few pieces and you can still see the whole picture. I mean, that's so that's the difference. Are you giving a theological education that's built? Hello, Jesus. Built on sand. So good. Or are you building on foundation that's going to last? And I think that that's really the difference between a Jenga tower and a mosaic. Um, you know, there aren't any Jenga towers left from the early church. Let's just say that. There's going to be all kinds of missteps and misunderstandings, and you might not feel like you're going to be completely welcomed in the way that you want. But I can almost completely guarantee you that probably nothing is going to happen in that building that is designed to purposefully hurt you or to control you. Wow. I want to go hear what you say about this because my sense of it was it, because I'd spent all this time in evangelicalism. I had never heard in the those 15 to 18 years one good thing about a mainline church. Correct. And as a matter of fact, not only did I not hear one good thing, I heard many bad and scary things. Like those people were all heretics. Uh, you know, they're demon worshippers. If you go in that church, you're gonna lose your salvation. Political.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Right? They're all political. Jokes on who now, you know.
SPEAKER_04I can't believe I just said that. But that's true. Um the evangelicals have become the new main line. And I could have told them. You, yeah, you probably did, and they just didn't listen. Oh no, they never listened to me because I was blacklisted before at Christianity Day so long ago that they probably forgot my name by now. Um, so um, so anyway, you know, so I I knew that what my friends were being told in evangelicalism was rotten to the core about the main line. It's just it was rotten, rotten, rotten, rotten, rotten. They are not Christians.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um, and I just couldn't believe it because I knew it wasn't true. My parents, my childhood church, people I still knew who I might have been a little worried about their salvation, but they actually were Methodists and they seemed to do it okay. And um, then I knew a lot of Episcopalians along the way. I knew a lot of Lutherans, and those people were kind of nice and they got things right, and that they clearly loved Jesus, and that's the thing. If somebody loves Jesus, you can't discount them. And um But they didn't pray that sinner's prayer, Diana. I know, yeah. No, what they do in those churches, Alexis, is they pray a sinner's prayer every single week. Every single week you get on your knees in the Episcopal Church and confess your sins and ask for forgiveness.
SPEAKER_08Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And so it's like, yeah, you don't pray one prayer. I don't know how many times I prayed a prayer for asking forgiveness of my sins in the Episcopal Church. A thousand, two thousand, ten thousand, something like that. So you just keep repeating it.
SPEAKER_07Welcome to the Sacred Slope Friends, where the slippery slope becomes sacred ground. I'm Alexis Rice, and I'm so excited because today we have Diana Butler Bass. A lot of you are going to be familiar with her. And for those who have not had the gift of hearing her speak or reading her writings from the cottage on Substack or from one of her many books, she has a new book that's called A Beautiful Year. It's so gorgeous. It's 52 meditations on faith, wisdom, and perseverance. And her newest book is so incredibly beautiful. A beautiful year, 52 meditations on faith, wisdom, and perseverance. The book takes us through the year following the Christian calendar, which we're gonna talk about because I now go to an Episcopal church. I regularly have no idea where we are in the Christian calendar still. Anne Lamont, Brian McLaren, and one of my absolute favorite people in the world, Bishop Marianne Edgar Buddy, who also has been on the sacred slope a couple times, writes on the back of her book to journey with Diana Butler Bass through the seasons of the year is to see familiar scenes with fresh eyes and gather amazing insights along the way. At once a teacher and fellow pilgrim, she is a wondrous guide. In a time where I am talking a lot about just a lot of the rough and painful things and how to find beautiful ways through them. One of my goals is to always make sure that I am showing you beautiful expressions of our Christian faith that might be outside of fundamentalism that you either grew up with or that you're curious about and you're like, I grew up in Christianity and my friend is a Baptist or they're an evangelical and they seem to just have a whole different framework for Christianity than I do. And they often do, that is true. We do talk about that some today. I'd like to introduce you to Diana. So I heard her speak years ago at Theology Beer Camp. I'll go into this in the show, but she started talking about the history of Christianity in America and this enormous world of Christianity that's outside the evangelical world that I knew. And something clicked. I thought, wait a minute, if I spent so much of my life, even deconstructing, not really understanding what other folks believe outside of my worldview, I'm sure other people feel the same. And so that was part of a catalyst for the sacred slope. I really think that it's important that no matter where we come from in the world, that studying other faiths and hearing from other people, it's a way that we can see a little bit more of our global diverse, inclusive faith. I mean, there's two billion Christians on the planet, over 45,000 denominations. We have a lot to learn from one another, and there's a huge menu to choose from. I also felt really betrayed. I'm just going to talk about this in the episode two. When I felt like, you know, there's one expression of Christianity that has become so dominant with the microphone, with the funding, with the organization, with the certainty, with all of the cool trimmings of the modern American evangelical church. I know that it can feel like that is the most up-to-date modern version of theology, but the truth is that it's normally not. And so once I learned that, I felt honestly super betrayed. And I wanted to say something for those who are in conservative evangelical fundamentalism and that's something that you want to stay in. I can respect that as long as you've wrestled, as long as you know and learn about atonement theories, as long as you learn about the different words for hell and how they were put into the Bible under one translation, as long as you learn about different ways that people all over the world hold evolution and genesis together, as long as you can understand the history of how a homosexual got put in the Bible as a mistranslation and was later redacted, as long as you can see that women have always been leading in the Bible, if you feel like you only understand one framework of understanding Christianity, if you were basically told, well, like God has to be a Republican and an American, and that America is like somehow exceptional to anywhere else in the world, like if you've heard those things and you honestly interrogated them with scholars, with other pastors, with other Christians outside of your framework, you've wrestled with that and you've decided to stay in conservative evangelical fundamentalism. I can respect that, but don't you owe it to yourself to wrestle. And for those of you who think that you're atheists or agnostics, and a lot of that was probably because you came from this fundamentalist point of view. I know that there's trauma there. I know that some of you have set that aside, but I do want to challenge you that you might not realize it, but I think you're still living in the evangelical fundamentalist framework of this binary that like you do not have access to a faith, to a connection with Jesus, to a connection with God because of the things that you are really against, whether that's racism or sexism or homophobia or bigotry, or, you know, like how people are treating immigrants or how there's American exceptionalism, there's a lot of really legitimate reasons that you left your local church space. That does not bar you from an opportunity to have a relationship in community with God, should you choose it. And so if you are ready to go on a journey where you are, as Diana Butler Bass will talk about in her book, how Jesus opened minds. If you're ready to go on that journey, this is a great episode to start with. I wanted to ask her today, what in the world is going on with Christianity? Um, that's way too big of a question for one episode, but I do want to start with telling you a little bit about why I respect Diana so much. First of all, she's actually Dr. Diana Butler Bass. She has a PhD from Duke. Yet I feel like I never hear anyone call her Dr. Diana Butler Bass, but it's important to know that she's incredibly well studied. She's an award-winning author of more than a dozen books, a speaker, a preacher, a historian, and trusted commentator on religion and contemporary spirituality. Her bylines include The New York Times, the Washington Post, USA Today, CNN Opinion, On Being, and Reader's Digest. She has appeared on CBS, CNN, PBS, NPR, and news outlets around the world. She also writes The Cottage, one of the most widely read substack newsletters on religion, spirituality, culture, and public life. Okay, time to dive in with Diana Butler Bass. I'm Alexis Rice, and today I finally get to ask the questions that I've been holding right here for years to the person I'm so excited to ask. Ladies and gentlemen, this is Diana Butler Bass. Hi, Diana.
SPEAKER_04Hi, Alexis. What a nice introduction. And um, I have always thought that slippery slopes were sacred ground. So we're right on the same wavelength there.
SPEAKER_07I love that. Yeah. I mean, it's crazy when you grow up in it, right? When you grew up in that fear of the sacred slope, I just had someone message me who's in her 40s and is starting the journey, right? And was like, oh, I'm just so scared because I've been told it's slippery, but I also see my faith expanding and I don't know what to do. Have you kind of had that personal story for yourself from like when you were young?
SPEAKER_04Well, uh, you know, my background is a little bit different than many people who go through these kinds of big faith transformations because I was born and raised in the Methodist church. So my my oldest memories of religion and, you know, just practicing faith are very tender and tied up with Methodism in the 1960s. And it was a very gentle kind of religious tradition. It was when I was 15 that I personally chose to join an evangelical church. It was it was my own choice of my own free will for lots of reasons that were tied up with being a teenager in the 1970s. So I journeyed through that for a long time, about 15, 18 years. It's it's hard to figure out exactly when the ending date was. But I remember being very scared when I finally realized that it had come to an end. And um I I don't know if this will help your listener or help uh help you, but I remember this time I was sitting and I was actually talking to uh a therapist and he was helping me. I was going through a divorce at the time, and we were sharing about my religious tradition and why I just couldn't sign the divorce papers. And and I said to him, Oh my gosh, I just feel like I I'm in I'm in a cage. I can't turn this way, I can't turn that way, I can't go back, I can't go forward. And he looked at me and he said, Well, the door is wide open. Just walk through it. And and I can remember sitting there just feeling like, What? The door is wide open? And I I couldn't imagine that the there was a you know, just free passage into a a different world. And I realized that the only thing that was holding me back there was my own fear. And at that point, I just stepped right through. And uh that that it hasn't been, you know, brilliantly easy all the time because I did spend a long time in evangelicalism. My life as a young adult was tied up in my friendships and my professional aspirations, and my I had gone to an evangelical college and seminary, and everything was it felt set on a particular faith trajectory, and then it wasn't. And and the choice was pretty clear either stay in a cage with myself holding the door shut, um, or just walk out. And that's that's what I did.
SPEAKER_07When you walked out, something I've noticed about you over reading your books and listening to you and seeing you at conferences over the years is that it seems to me that you always took Jesus with you wherever you went.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, he sort of stuck. He stuck around for the the journey, you know. It's like we we've been on it together. And I mean, I think that that is one of the real gifts and and kind of a difference from my uh journey uh beyond evangelicalism, than many of my friends and people I know have really struggled with that. And it goes back to my childhood because uh Jesus, I I I've been lecturing a lot this month on religion and politics, as you might guess, as we're heading into the 2026 elections, uh, while we're recording. And um I've been telling this story on the road about how the first two names of any human beings that I knew other than my parents, and I don't even think I knew my parents' names when I knew these other two names because you only know mommy and daddy. I had no idea that my parents were Bob and Marcia. And uh so uh I I was born in 1959, which means in 1960, um, I was, you know, a year old. And my that was an election year. And my mother was a very young woman, and I was her only child at that time. And so she worked as a campaign worker for uh John Kennedy, and she would just put me in the stroller, and she wasn't a very high-level staffer or anything. She literally passed out brochures, she helped at polling, you know, she went to campaign rallies, very simple things. And um, so anyway, but she take me, you know, in the stroller. And so she swore to me years later that the two names that I said before when I first learned how to talk were um Jesus, because I was in church as a little baby to Methodist Church, and John F. Kennedy.
SPEAKER_05Oh wow. And so those are the two names that I knew before I knew any other names, Jesus and John F. Kennedy.
SPEAKER_04And I've I've sometimes joked with Kristen Covez Zumei. I was gonna say, I said, you might write a book called Jesus and John Wayne, but honestly, honey, I would I grew up mainline Protestant and my first two names were were Jesus and John Kennedy, and I think I got the better end of that deal.
SPEAKER_07Wow. You know, okay, I've been thinking about lately, like, how can we differentiate kind of the different strands of Christianity and stuff? And maybe we just say, like, you know, sometimes I've been going back and like, are you a Pete Heggseth or a Dolly Parton Christian, right? But maybe it's the are you with this Jesus and John Wayne or the Jesus and John Kennedy?
unknownThere you go.
SPEAKER_04And so, you know, Jesus was just always there in Methodism, that that childhood Methodism, the first image of Jesus that I ever knew. And I I write about this in Freeing Jesus, uh, was Jesus as my friend. And that's really true. You grew up in Methodism in the 1960s the way that I did. Jesus was this warm, engaging figure. I remember still to this day, the picture that hung in my first ever Sunday school classroom was Jesus being surrounded by all these little children and the little children that were in the painting. It actually is a very famous painting. I've since looked it up. And um, I'm not the only Methodist who remembers this painting. Um so uh it all the little children from different ethnicities. And I remember looking at that picture as my Sunday school teacher would read us, you know, stories about Jesus and how Jesus loved the little children, let the little children come to me. And there was one girl um in that painting that was blonde and who looked, you know, Anglo-Northern European, and she was standing right next to Jesus, and she had her her her chin cheek on on Jesus' shoulder. And when I saw that painting for the very first time, or at least, you know, as it came into my awareness as a child, um, I thought, oh, that's me. And so I was always the little girl that was standing right next to Jesus with her her cheek on Jesus' shoulder. And um years later, when uh freeing Jesus came out, I was on a podcast with a bunch of guys who were uh very cool, um uh ex-evangelicals. And most of I think uh there were three hosts and two of them had become mainline pastors and yet they had grown up in very rigid forms of evangelicalism. And so one of them said to me that this image of Jesus as friend was so compelling to him that he said, you know, I grew up Southern Baptist, and he said, Take my word for it, that was not the image of Jesus that we had in my church growing up. And I I was sort of baffled. I said, Well, what was the image of Jesus when you were a little kid? And he said, Oh, Jesus was scary because Jesus was going to judge us at the last day. And I I I thought to myself, I I d I literally couldn't understand a world that was shaped like that for children where Jesus was a a frightening figure. And so when he gave me this little sort of mini testimony, um, uh uh it made me realize how much of a gift that 1960s Methodism for his uh people always um accuse Methodism of being sort of sentimental and even hyper pious in an old-fashioned sort of way uh of devotion. Um very privatized. Um but uh but I think it was really beautiful. Jesus was my friend. And so that's really you know, you say that and I'm like, Well sometimes what you learn when you're two years old sticks. And and so I've never felt afraid of Jesus. I never understood Jesus as a warrior, I never understood Jesus as anyone except for this incredible, loving, embracing uh friend who accompanies us and who goes ahead of us. Um, scripture even says that I go ahead of you to the place that you do not know, but I'll meet you there. And so all that kind of gentleness has always been a just very deep part of my own spirituality. And I was never able, even in all those years I was in evangelicalism, I was never able to reconcile uh the Jesus that I was being taught in uh Bible churches and Pentecostal churches uh with that Jesus that I had known since before I really have much. Of a memory of anything else. So that's uh, yeah, Jesus goes with me. And um, you know, it doesn't mean that Jesus is always the same, because I'm pretty sure whoever wrote Hebrews, Jesus is the same yesterday, today, and forever. I always say, well, that might be true for Jesus, but that's not true for us. So maybe Jesus is the same, uh, that that incredible figure of total love. Um, but we change through our whole lives, which means we encounter Jesus differently. And so that means that for me, and I think for people who take uh sort of the Christian journey seriously with Jesus, um, Jesus eventually begins to have many faces as we go through our lives. So yeah, I like Jesus a lot.
SPEAKER_07You know, what's so helpful about that to me is the more that I've been talking to folks around the world that have different traditions, right, backgrounds, the more I have realized how wildly different um the images, kind of the core fundamental beliefs we have, and then the assumptions we make about what others might believe, and then the assumptions others make about what all Christians believe, right? So that's worse right now because MAG is apparently representing all of us, two billion of us around the world. Um sorry to ignite you right away, but we'll we'll put that lid in for a minute. Sorry.
SPEAKER_05Like move that over to the closet.
SPEAKER_07But you know, I think it is so beautiful to have these kinds of conversations because you are one of the people, like I am, and like several of the people on the show who are translators. I coined this, you know, kind of translator, which means you would be able to explain to a progressive pastor what an ex-evangelical might be feeling coming into a mainline church for the first time. You would be able to explain those tripwires, the fear, the formation. And then you would be able to go to an evangelical pastor and be able to talk about, hey, these are the different ways that you know we see scripture or that other people see scripture, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I've actually done both of those things in my life.
SPEAKER_07I've seen you, and I was like, okay, yes, we need more translators in this world. And we also need translators right now, I think, for the media, for people outside of Christianity to be able to come in and say, hey, this is what's going on with MAGA. These are the roots of this. This is where this is coming from. This is why there is a, as Kristen actually talked about, and I had this coffee cup when she was here when we were interviewing as a tongue-in-cheek. But, you know, that there's like this closed system, even though, you know, it's open, that there is this closed system that I don't think people outside of it really can see. And I think that folks like this right now are secret weapons and um underutilize superpowers in order to help building bridges. Very excited to kind of talk to you about this today. So, all right, so here's my personal Diana Butler Bass story. So I first saw you speak many years ago at Theology Beer Camp in North Carolina. And at that point, I actually didn't know a lot of people in this world yet. Okay. I knew Trip Fuller from Homebrewed Christianity because I listened to Trip a lot. That had become a lifeline for me. I knew Pete Ends and Jared Bias from the Bible for normal people of Christianity, uh, you know, after living mostly in evangelical circles for my life. And then there's this funny personal connection to you. So my parents' stepdad and their whole family, and they're all in their 70s now, went to this small Christian college in California in the 70s. Um, you might know of it. And many of their closest college friends, they are like my aunties. They are these women in my life. And so when I was at beer camp, and I said, Oh, there's this woman there, um, Diana, Diana Butler, you know, and they went, Diana Butler, Bass. And they completely just that it was the best thing to see the way that you had shaped their faith and saved them in giving them language to all these things that they had been experiencing over the course of their lifetime, right? And that you had been a shining star, a beacon to hold on to faith and yet explore it with just fearlessness. When I heard you speak, you started talking about the history of evangelical Christianity in America and this enormous world outside. And something clicked for me. You showed a chart. It talked about the percentages of evangelical Christians in the United States. And then it also showed the percentage of mainline Christians and how I think they were roughly the same amount of people. Is that right?
SPEAKER_04Um, that has been true now for about a decade, especially uh it wasn't true in older generations of Americans. So if you just looked at people who were over 50, you'd still see an imbalance. There were more white evangelicals than there were white mainliners. But it it changes. When you get down to Gen X, you begin to see uh it evening out by millennial generation. It's almost completely even between the number of people in that generation who were white and who were evangelicals and white who were who were mainline. And my daughter, who's uh Gen Z, it's completely equal. As a matter of fact, I think the last chart I saw had like it was like one point higher, which is essentially equal. But um, it might be the first time I've ever seen the percentage of white mainliners generationally be higher than white evangelicals. So yeah, when I show that chart, people will be pretty shocked because their idea was that mainline religion was dead. Um, why would anybody join that? This is all the dying churches. Yeah, we've been dying, mainline churches. Uh, I eventually became an Episcopalian. So I Methodists did this sort of transportation sort of thing, this transit through uh evangelicalism, and then uh came out on the other side and I was an Episcopalian, which happens to a surprising amount of people, by the way.
SPEAKER_05Yes, I'm also in the Episcopal Church now.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's on our way. It's not an uncommon journey. So, you know, people just don't know that that's happened because these denominations they have struggled a lot over the last 70 years. And they used to be the biggest ones. If we put ourselves back in the year I was born in uh 1959, 1960, um, those were the largest Protestant denominations in the country. And evangelicalism would barely be a blip on anybody's chart. And so what happened, of course, was in the late 20th century, evangelicalism sort of took off like a shot, especially in its public discussion. Once Jimmy Carter was elected president in 76, it was just like that's all anybody could talk about. Who are these people? You know, what do they believe? And then the moral majority and all these folks who became incredibly famous, um, mostly around their combination of religion and politics, Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, the whole gang. And um meanwhile, the mainline churches were really kind of struggling. They were struggling to hold on to their youth. They sort of lost their way a little bit in the culture. When they were no longer dominant, they didn't know how to be. And so the old mainline, I mean, their name even, we're the mainline Protestants, which is kind of a crazy name now because I often consider them the legacy Protestants. It's sort of like the legacy media, you know, they're still around, just not as big and as influential as they used to be. And so the mainline of these legacy groups really worked hard to find their footing. Um, and I think that they began to find that footing in the 1990s. So just when evangelicals were entering into purity culture and all kinds of things that would be so traumatizing for an incredible number of younger people who were in those evangelical churches, uh, the mainline was just really beginning to find a sense of its voice, again, around spiritual practices, around uh feminist theology, around its inclusion of gay people, around a sort of real wrestling for the first time in its history about race and the legacy of racism in those churches. And I really want to link this to spiritual practices because spiritual it wasn't just like these social movements began to impact mainline Protestantism, and that that was what gave it kind of some new life. It was this really beautiful link that began to develop and still is present now between the ritual life, the spiritual practice life of individuals, and the life of social justice, and trying to figure out how those three things essentially make a triad of the foundation uh that goes underneath now of the Episcopal Church. I think the United Church of Christ, the Disciples of Christ, the Presbyterians, etc. And so when people go into those churches, you know, there's still a lot of old folks, there's still a lot of people who are kind of clueless, still a lot of people who are mourning the fact that the the 1950s are no longer. Um, but if you find the right church, what you're gonna find is uh people who are theologically literate, yes, um, very interested um and engaged in all kinds of different social issues, and people who have really uh some very beautiful and uh even what we would call ancient spiritual practices, contemplative prayer, labyrinth walking is incredibly popular in mainline churches. The music has shifted. Um, you might find some you know, sort of 1990s style bands someplace. I haven't seen one in a long time.
SPEAKER_06You you hit my hot button, Diana. This is my biggest, biggest gripe and complaint with the mainline churches. I'm like, and some contemporary, all these ex-vangelicals are just sitting at home sad and alone.
SPEAKER_04Don't do that. Uh but there's a lot more contemplative music, there's a lot more newer hymns that are being experimented with. Uh, so it's just a matter of of kind of landing um in a congregation that is both what I would consider to be sort of historically grounded and uh attentive to its tradition, but that there's a lot of experimentation in very interesting good ways going on. So that's a big part of my career. I realized that that was happening when nobody else kind of did. And I started writing about it. And that meant that pastors and denominational executives started calling me up. It's starting saying, What do you mean you found vital mainline churches? And I said, Yeah, I found a lot of them. Um, this is what I'm seeing. And then they'd want me to come and, you know, talk to their diocese, their synod, their group, their seminary. I did a lot of that. I don't really focus so much on that anymore because that work is continuing. I think denominations are making and have made decisions about all those different things, about their identities. And now that work is the really the work of the people moving ahead. So I'm more confident in their abilities and their vision uh to make a new future for themselves than I was, say, 25 years ago. And that's where I went when I left evangelicalism. See, I had a place to go. Tell us about that. I went back to something that was familiar. And um, it just so happened that I was living in Santa Barbara at the time. I was teaching at uh an evangelical college there, and I was in trouble um with my job at that institution. Santa Barbara's kind of a small town, and everybody sort of knows everybody else's business, um, probably even still now. So people had heard, you know, that there was this woman who was a professor in religious studies who was on unsteady ground with her employers. That's the best way to put it. But I began getting letters from mainline pastors around Santa Barbara saying that they were praying for me and if I needed to talk, they were there for me. And it was really amazing because uh through that process, I eventually was no longer teaching at that college. But what I found out was that the people in Santa Barbara who had stood up for me were all of the mainline clergy. Wow. And they didn't even know me. And they just heard that something was happening that was unjust. And so they inserted themselves. That's what mainline pastors do the best. They love inserting themselves in unjust situations. And so um, so they inserted themselves in my um unpleasant situation, and that meant that I lost all these friends in evangelicalism, but I turned around and I had a whole bunch of new friends, people I didn't even know before the fact. So I went back to the religious tradition that I knew. The Methodist Church in Santa Barbara at that time wasn't very um alive. It was a a troubled congregation of the one that I would have gone to um in my neighborhood. Um, but still around though. God bless them. They're still in business and they're I don't know, I think they're doing better now from uh from everything I've heard. Um, but I went to an Episcopal church down the street um from that Methodist church and uh yeah, kind of fell in love actually with the people, with the building, with the tradition, with the ritual. Um it was very close to Methodism because um Methodism is an offspring from um Anglicanism at its first back in the um 18th century. So there were very familiar parts of the liturgy, very familiar parts of the hymnity that were shared by both traditions. And so um, yeah. So I wound up getting in trouble at the evangelical college, and I became a member of the only Episcopal church in all of Southern California that in the early 1990s had an out-gay priest.
SPEAKER_07I'm not surprised that there was only one. I mean, I grew up in Southern California as well, and like that would just just not present.
SPEAKER_04No, it wasn't. Even in 93, 94, 95. It was just, it was, it was novel. So I mean, it was kind of hilarious. You know, I sort of proved the case that I didn't fit at the evangelical college by winding up at the Episcopal Church with the outgate priest, and he wound up being one of my best friends and still is somebody who is incredibly dear to me to this day. So I had a place to go. And that's the thing that pisses me off, excuse my language, about people leaving evangelicalism. Yes, let's get into it.
SPEAKER_06This was actually my next question. Let's do it. Was it? Yes.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. See, I'm always jumping ahead in my mind to what the next question might be, but I want I want to hear what you say about this because my sense of it was it, because I'd spent all this time in evangelicalism. I had never heard in the those 15 to 18 years one good thing about a mainline church. Correct. And as a matter of fact, not only did I not hear one good thing, I heard many bad and scary things. Like those people were all heretics. Uh, you know, they're demon worshippers. If you go in that church, you're gonna lose your salvation. Political.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Right? They're all political. Jokes on who now, you know.
SPEAKER_04I can't believe I just said that. But that's true. Um the evangelicals have become the new main line. And I could have told them. You, yeah, you probably did, and they just didn't listen. Oh no, they never listened to me because I was blacklisted before at Christianity Day so long ago that they probably forgot my name by now. Um, so um, so anyway, you know, so I I knew that what my friends were being told in evangelicalism was rotten to the core about the main line. It's just it was rotten, rotten, rotten, rotten, rotten. They are not Christians.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um, and I just couldn't believe it because I knew it wasn't true. My parents, my childhood church, people I still knew who I might have been a little worried about their salvation, but they actually were Methodists and they seemed to do it okay. And um, and then I knew a lot of Episcopalians along the way, I knew a lot of Lutherans, and those people were kind of nice and they got things right, and that they clearly loved Jesus, and that's the thing. If somebody loves Jesus, you can't discount them. And um But they didn't pray that sinner's prayer, Diana. I know. Yeah. No, what they do in those churches, Alexis, is they pray a sinner's prayer every single week. Every single week you get on your knees in the Episcopal Church and confess your sins and ask for forgiveness. Yeah. And so it's like, yeah, you don't pray one prayer. I don't know how many times I prayed a prayer for asking forgiveness of my sins in the Episcopal Church. A thousand, two thousand, ten thousand, something like that. So you just keep repeating it.
SPEAKER_07It's helpful. I think the next few questions are going to be can you be translated or Diana to a few different audiences? Um, because you're so good at this. And one of this is the evangelical side of things. Like, you know, when people are looking at folks who were raised in evangelicalism and then they just leave or they're kicked out and now there's no faith. There's nothing in between. And my hunch is that it's because they only know this binary, right? They only know because they were raised in evangelicalism. We were told you are either sold out, fully on fire for God, or you're out, right? Even though they say they're atheist or not in the faith now. I think they're still subscribing to the evangelical framework of Christianity, which is so wildly different than so many of the different denominations you've named. So I was wondering if you could just be a little bit of a translator right now for evangelicals who are like, this is rotten fruit everywhere, but I don't want to leave my faith, but I'm freaked out because I've only been told horrible things about all these other denominations.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you know, I'm well aware of the shortcomings of the mainline in the same way that I am well aware of the shortcomings of evangelicalism. Yet there's a profound difference between them. And that is the mainline, its shortcomings tend to be hubris, um, kind of isolation from other religious traditions. You know, even Lutherans and Episcopalians don't always talk to each other in ways that are helpful. Um, so it's a little bit of hubris. You know, we have this ancient tradition and it's wonderful. And you're just going to come along and join us, you know, eventually you'll figure it out. You come. Um, so that's the the hubris part of it. That isolation, that that episcopal world or Methodist world or Presbyterian world is the most important world. Um and then I would say klutziness. They're just kind of klutsy. Um, and what I mean by that is I have had friends who are evangelicals who get brave enough to walk into the doors of one of these old churches. And the very first thing that happens is that some nice, well-meaning uh person, always over 75, asks them if they'll teach Sunday school. And so I I always just want to shake my head at that. I mean, it just that that's the exact wrong thing is that if an ex-evangelical happens to wander into a mainline church, you don't look at them as kind of fresh meat for your Sunday school program because people who used to be evangelicals know when they're being used. And so if you get asked to give to the storytam too often, and you ask you people want you to fill up all these different roles that they can no longer do because most of them are too old to do them still, is that then the person thinks, well, does anybody care about me getting to know me and my spiritual life? And what do these people have to offer my spiritual life if they just want me to, you know, join the flower guild? And what the heck is a flower guild? And so, so, so they're klutzy because they've been in these smaller universes of theology and tradition for so long, and they also can be pretty generationally isolated because there was this hollowing out of their traditions, particularly with the baby boomers. Baby boomers left. They often it's so funny to me that millennials sometimes blame everything that's gone wrong in the main line with baby boomers. It's like the few of us that are there, we actually chose um over and opposed to most of our friends who left church. And you know, some of those people came. Back to church. But really, for as many baby boomers as there are in the world, there are lots of them that aren't religious and they're in lots of other different kinds of religious traditions. They're not all mainliners. So yeah, the hollowing out happened in my generation. And so that meant that my generation sort of began to thin. And then those next generations, they started to disappear. And um, yeah, so it's been hard on them. And so their their churches are aging. Um, and they don't really understand a lot of times how to relate to younger adults. And they so so it's it's been very difficult, difficult, I think, for them. So I think it's they're clueless, they're kind of klutzy. Well, I'll give you an example.
SPEAKER_07I was asked to speak at a wonderful, it was a a lot of UCC pastors in the Northeast. Wonderful, wonderful pastors, like the most amazing theology, they all had several degrees, PhDs, which I was like blowing my evangelical brain, where like, you know, there's this 19-year-old kid who's like a pastor and apparently he knows as much as, you know, anyway. So it's all these really, really smart, incredible humans. And when I told them what was going on in evangelicalism and how that relates to MAGA, like jaws on the floor. Right. I even had some pastors, and I'm so appreciative that they shared this with me of saying, you know, if we have gay folks coming in uh that were raised in evangelical churches and they're wounded birds, you know, they're traumatized. And I don't even know where to start with them because I don't know what they were told, you know, um, as like these are non-negotiable beliefs. And those non-negotiable beliefs are like not present in a lot of the mainline churches, but there was not even an awareness at all, despite the fact that we have Christian nationalism going on all around us. Um, does that resonate with you, that story?
SPEAKER_04Yes, it completely does. Uh one of my sort of favorite, this happened for several years before MAGA came to the fore. And um, that was uh people, every single event I went to in a church, people would say, How do we get the young people to come to church? And I would always say, the very first thing you do is stop asking that question. That's right. A hundred percent don't ask that question. That's the wrong any adult under 40 hears you ask that question, they're gonna run out the door. I said, that's not the question. And so they said, Well, what are the questions? And I said, Well, young adults are really concerned about things like if I came to this church and wanted to get married, could my best friend who was gay be my maid bonner? Or, you know, or my my best man? Or um, what is this church doing to stem the threat of the climate crisis? There's a just a whole host of questions, but those were the main two ones that I thought about a lot was uh LGBTQ stuff and environmentalism. Those are sort of been my driving issues for most of my adult life. There are other political questions that came to the fore along the way, economic inequality, et cetera. And so I would tell people, uh, because then people would proudly tell me, we're doing everything, you know, to make sure that we're welcoming, blah, blah, blah. And um what I knew is that they had specifically given me directions that I was never supposed to, when I was preaching in their church, talk about religion and politics. And I said, Well, you're going to have to figure out how to talk about religion and politics. And people would look at me, they're shocked. And they would say, Oh, we can't talk about that. Because if we talk about that, we're going to alienate our biggest donors. Or if we talk about that, you know, half of the people in the congregation are gonna go away. And I said, And as a matter of fact, there was one church I went to that literally had a sign out front that said, we talk about Jesus, not religion and politics. Okay. And I said, you know what, that sign out front, you might have just hung up a sign that says, No one under 40 is welcome here. I said, because the main issues that are the driving issues of adults under 40 in this culture are all political. So when you hang out a sign like that, you're saying their issues don't matter to you. And they're gonna drive right past your door. And I said, and I don't know where they're gonna go. They probably aren't gonna go anywhere. They're probably gonna go, you know, play sports or whatever, whatever they want to do on a Sunday morning sleep in. I said, because it's gonna be more interesting, frankly, than coming to a church where nobody wants to talk about what really matters. And and so people would absolutely be shocked when I would say that. And yet that cluelessness just has persisted. At the same time, I would also turn around and tell them, I said, you may not be talking about religion politics, but I can absolutely guarantee you that that big evangelical mega church down the street, they're talking about religion politics all the time. And they're talking about religion politics in a way that you're not gonna like. And then they go.
SPEAKER_07They're also gonna do it in this way where they frame it as being apolitical, though. It's just Jesus. It's just what like the example that always comes to me is I don't know how many people who are outside who are in politics in the United States, like politicians and political strategists. Do you know that most of the evangelical churches give the sermon the week before elections that says, well, we're not gonna tell you how to vote. But no Christian can vote for right. For a liberal, right? Right. Vote blue. And that it's like if you're not even addressing, you know, this thing, this is where the translators, I think, come in, right? Like progressive Christians don't seem to be that aware of what's going on. And progressives who are not Christians aren't really speaking to Christians, conservative Christians, moderate Christians who grew up in evangelicalism. All these things that we were told like this is what it means to be a faithful Christian, everything else doesn't count.
SPEAKER_04Right. Yeah, I mean, that's exactly right. It's I would go on and try to explain to people that what was happening down the street is exactly what you just said.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_04Is that they were actually telling people how to vote. They just usually waited until the Sunday before the election. And the other thing was, I also knew that the whole way along, every every sermon where they could squeeze it in, they were saying that Democrats were of the devil. Yep.
SPEAKER_07Democrats, demon rats, yes, yeah, something to that to that effect.
SPEAKER_04And and so liberal Christians and Democrats were Satan possessed. So they were literally recruiting their entire congregation uh for the GOP, week after week after week after week after week. And so then I said, okay, so you don't talk about religion and politics because you don't like that. I'm not urging you to get up into the pulpit and say that every person who is a member of the GOP is, you know, is doomed to hell forever. What I'm asking you to do is to talk about faith and political life and engage these issues the ways that you think the Bible might engage them. And though, and and so, you know, what what does the Bible say about creation care? What does the Bible say about human dignity? What does the Bible say about the rich and the poor? What does the Bible say about the rights of women? What does the Bible say about all these things? And so those are that's a way of talking about religion and politics. I'm not asking you to be partisan and telling everybody that that Republicans are are doomed. Um, but what you need to do is you need to understand the theopolitical. I love these kinds of words. You can use these words in mainline churches and nobody looks at you like you're crazy, you know. I like that. You have to be able to talk about and explain the theopolitical vision of Jesus. That's your bare minimum. And beyond that, talk about it in relationship to the Presbyterian tradition. Talk about it in relationship to uh the Episcopal tradition. And also maybe it helps to learn a thing or two about the Hebrew Bible. Um, because oh, you know, all this time when evangelicals are down the street are convincing people that Donald Trump is King Cyrus, um, I'm sitting there reading about God having a discussion with Samuel about whether or not Israel should have kings. And one of the most important chapters in the whole of the Hebrew scriptures is that discussion when the people of Israel come to God and they say, Hey, everybody around us has a king. We want a king too. And they do it through the prophet Samuel. And so God says back to him, he says, No, it's a bad idea. Um, you don't want a king. Really trust me on this. And though the people come back and they say, We want a king, we want a king, we want a king. God says, No. Finally, God then explains it. And God says, Well, if you get a king, I can absolutely guarantee you that your sons will be recruited for war, that the kings will steal from you, they will take your money, they will raise your taxes, they will ruin your crops, and that there will be inequality and instability in your society that will create more violence and it will create more division than what you think you have now. And so God says, No, no, no kings, don't do it, no kings. That's the central theopolitical vision of the Hebrew Bible is no kings. Um, and so they said, No, we still want a king. And God says, Okay, I'm gonna give you what you want. You ask. And so then God gives the people of Israel what they want, and that destroys destroys them. And then the prophets, the rest of the Hebrew Bible is the prophets trying to correct the mistake that the Israelites made by asking for a king. And so I wonder where that sermon has been in the Southern Baptist Church down the street. That's a sermon that can be preached, though, in any Presbyterian church in this country or any Lutheran church or any UCC church or any Episcopal church and should be preached. And it's absolutely clear what it's about. And you don't have to say Donald Trump's name. No. Just preach the sermon because that's the Hebrew Bible. And so to me, that's the sort of the passionate genius of these mainline churches. Once they sort of gave up being in charge of society and tried to find their footing again, what they began to go back to, um, and they've done this surprisingly well in many places, is really these deep wells of theological tradition that they have always had. And they do have extraordinary skill, at least in their leadership, the clergy and a lot of their trained leadership throughout the whole system, are people who are extraordinarily well educated.
SPEAKER_07Yes. That's what's been so interesting to me is just hearing from people who are in seminary, who went to seminary, who have PhDs. Like when I asked uh Dr. Jennifer Garcia Bashat, who you know, right? When I I had her on the show and I was asking about rapture theology for the, you know, for that time. And I was like, do most scholars who study the Bible like believe in the rapture. They don't believe in it. And she was like, I don't know any serious scholar who believes in the rapture, but you know Diana as an evangelical. It's hard to process it because you're like, well, I don't understand. I do feel sometimes like a lot of the scholars that I've talked to are just like, yeah, so silly, ridiculous. And all of us over here were going, we we've been in apologetics classes and Wednesday night Bible studies and more Bible studies on Sundays. We're like so in church, and yet we're not getting any of this education. What is up with that?
SPEAKER_04Well, it's a different education. I mean, honestly, it's not an education. You're educated into rapture theology and dispensational premillennialism. So congratulations. You actually know that better than most people with PhDs in theology who went to mainline seminaries. So it is an education, it's just a different form. And so I actually got, I mean, really, I mean, I'm theologically bilingual. I was educated by both. And so, so I really understand how I I don't devalue that. What I do, I just think it's wrong. I think it's a it's a terrible misinterpretation of scripture and not understanding the historical context of of scripture. Um, but I don't think it's it's not an education. Um, maybe we want to say propaganda, but I I yeah, I mean, even there I I'm hesitant because what you learned was actually intellectually consistent internally. And so when like evangelicals, I remember they used to say, well, if you pull out just sort of one piece of it, it's like a Jenga tower. And if you pull out one piece of it, the whole thing falls. That's exactly right. And this is my good news for evangelicals who are listening to us. Mainline theology is not a Jenga tower. Yeah, mainline theology is a mosaic. And that means you can lose a few pieces and you can still see the whole picture. And so I mean, that's so that's the difference. Are you giving a theological education that's built? Hello, Jesus, built on sand.
SPEAKER_11So good.
SPEAKER_04Or are you building on foundation that's going to last? And I think that that's really the difference between a Jenga tower and a mosaic. Um, you know, there aren't any Jenga towers left from the early church. Let's just say that. Um, but there are plenty of mosaics, actually, that still exist from the very time that Jesus and the disciples were walking around. You can still see the pictures. I guess my sort of whole thesis in this question that you've raised here is that when you walk into a mainline church, you might get bored to death. People might say really stupid things to you. Everyone's gonna be way older than you are. They're gonna try to recruit you for the Sunday school to teach Sunday school. I mean, there's gonna be all kinds of missteps and misunderstandings, and you might not feel like you're gonna be completely welcomed in the way that you want. But I can almost completely guarantee you that probably nothing is going to happen in that building that is designed to purposefully hurt you or to control you.
SPEAKER_08Wow.
SPEAKER_04Now you can run into a sick mainline church with a bad pastor, and those things can happen anywhere. Human sin. We got that. It's it's plenty, it's everywhere, it's in everything. Um, but for the most part, those are the sins. Now, I cannot guarantee the same in mainline churches, or I mean in evangelical churches, where I think that there is as I mean, this was so telling when Russ Vaught, in the months before uh Trump was inaugurated, and there well, I think it was even before he was elected, um, it was very clear that Russ Vaught, a Wheaton College graduate and evangelical Christian, was going to be the head of the, well, he was one of the writers of the pro of Project 2025.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_04And so he was trying to, you know, defend it, uh, make it look not as bad as it was, which is also a strategy in evangelicalism. You make it look less bad than it is, so that people come to you and they say, Oh, it's not so bad. Um, you know, they just mean it for our good, whatever. Yeah. All the welcome signs, yeah. Yeah, yeah. And I mean, I've been deluded by that plenty of times. But Russ Vaught was caught on tape, secretly recorded, saying that as soon as they got into office, his intent was to purposefully traumatize all of the federal workers in order that they would leave their jobs or they could fire them easily. He said, We want to put the federal workforce in trauma. And he said it with a big, yeah, he did. It was all over the media at the time. And so he said it with a big smile on his face. And I just looked at that and I went, he learned that in evangelical church. Because that's actually a learned strategy, what he was talking about right there. Is that if you put a group of people into trauma, you can control them. They'll either leave or you own them. Those are the only two possibilities. And so I thought to myself, but yeah, he's just described something that goes on. But not in every evangelical church, there are nice ones. I have known some nice ones along the way. But that's the dominant position of the most well-known leaders and biggest congregations in evangelicalism is that you put people in a state of trauma, be it uh simply telling them that they're going to go to hell over and over again, that they're going to be left behind. Since we were little tiny children. Yeah. It was purposeful putting people into trauma. Um, and so what I can say is that your chances are very good if you walk into an evangelical church that what you're going to encounter is you're going to encounter a system that wants to hurt you. And they're doing it, they say, for your own good. Walk into a mainline church, you're encountering a system that's out of step, doesn't really know what it's doing all the time. As I said, it's kind of klutzy, might hurt you by accident, but there's no there the the goodness, niceness, and kindness are their dominant moral, it's their dominant moral framework. And that's the difference. You know, I'm sorry to have to say that. It sounds like, you know, oh, she hates evangelicals. I do not. I do not. What I'm morally opposed to is the leadership and the theology that has manipulated millions and millions and millions of Americans and people around the world to the point where they are controllable in theological and social manner in order to accomplish goals that other people who do not have their best interests have. That just breaks my heart. I mean, that's the the place I get mad. I get mad at the leadership because it is purposefully doing this to human beings. And I have no sympathy for that. That to me, you know, if you want to use the Bible again. That's a very description of what um the Bible refers to as false prophets. And this is why evangelicals don't like me, because I love Jesus and I quote the Bible back to that's right.
SPEAKER_07Yes, and this is so effective. The ones who are doing this on social media right now, these big mainline pastors, I've interviewed a ton of them, they are the ones who are the translators who know exactly what you said, and they are able to take our faith and show how a lot of evangelical systems are being weaponized against people, and they're able to expose a mirror to it, right? Just like what you were saying.
SPEAKER_04I look I look at most evangelicals in this sort of political moment, and you're beginning to see it on actual interviews on television news is they say, I feel so deceived. Yes. And so that's what I've always understood about this is that there are MAGA true believers, and they're, you know, they're probably somewhere around 20% of the population. And that means that there are a lot, there are a lot of them in evangelical churches because that's the church that's coddled them all the way through this. Um, but there's a lot of people who have been abused, who have been deceived, and that means that the people who are their leaders are now responsible for that deception. And they blame Donald Trump, but honest to goodness, Donald Trump wouldn't have gotten as far as he did without a whole bunch of other people in a particular sort of corner of the media. And sadly enough, I mean, I don't know what the latest numbers are, but the last numbers I saw said that 67% of white evangelicals still supported Donald Trump. Now, that to me is actually an improvement. It is. It's better from 81. It's better from 81. It's better from 81. And so that means that there are at least now a some uh a sort of a fungible group now in some white evangelical churches and you know cultures in the United States who are looking at this and asking them this question have I been deceived? And the answer. Is yes, you have been. And I'm sorry for that. But Jesus actually warned us that that would happen. So it's not your fault. Um, but what is now your fault, if if you're asking yourself the question, have I been deceived? and you think that it's probably the case that you have been, then go and sin no more. Your job now is to pick it up and to say to yourself, okay, well, I'm deceived. So am I just so mad that I'm going to leave Christianity altogether? It's Christianity's fault, whatever. Or am I going to figure out where I went wrong, go back to that place, humbly admit my own mistakes, and find out where the journey takes me next. I highly recommend the second choice, even though a lot of people have made the first choice. And I get why they do make that first choice, but it breaks my heart because there really are other options out there. Um, and I wish that there was more healing and more understanding that was instantly available. You walked into a nice Lutheran church. I wish they could just fix it all for you. They won't be able to. But, you know, eventually you might find that there's a different path in those places, and you'll come to understand it and maybe even know it as your own.
SPEAKER_07Oh my gosh, I'm just I don't know why I'm feeling emotional talking with you. I just feel like I want to give you a hug. I feel like you see me. I feel like you see people. Um, and I I really thank you. Um, because man, it's it's a lot. And people were trying to just be good Christians in the system. It's the dominant system in the United States. You walk into like a regular evangelical modern church, it looks fun. You go look at the other churches and like, yeah, they are, they look boring, traditional, there's full of old people, or there's like this really cool church with like amazing music and fun games, and they want to shatter the stereotype that church is boring and it's amazing. And then you find out all of this stuff. And it's so incredibly like jarring and disorienting for millions and millions of people right now who are grieving. I think that there are people who have left church, but they didn't want to leave God, they didn't want to leave their faith, but they don't know that there's other options. And I I do blame that on our mainline um media and church infrastructure currently. I think that there's not an awareness, there's not a brand awareness. Uh, you know, unless you're like really into Christian-y worlds, like you don't really see it, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. That one of the perpetual problems, of course, of the mainline is that the hubris piece means that they just always thought that people would know that they were there. And then they had this privatized spirituality that has always been quiet. It was quiet when I was a kid.
SPEAKER_07That's what Hillary Clinton said. I remember as a Methodist, and she said, I have a quieter faith. And at the time I didn't understand.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it is a very quiet universe. And they value that. Right. As a matter of fact, mainline services often have long sections of silence in them. Um, and so it it is not the kind of tradition that will brand itself. That kind of cuts against its very heart. Um I go, I go to uh people always say, where do you go to church? You know, thinking that I must go to someplace that's really cool. I I I go to this tiny little Episcopal church that's in my neighborhood that I can walk to. Same. And and it's just like um my neighbors are kind of goofy. And yet, you know, I go there. I don't even go to the big service, which has probably maybe a hundred people, 125 people on a Sunday morning. I go to the little evening service, which on a big night we might get 25. So, and almost everybody who goes to that service is older than me, which is really like that's getting old. There are people there who could be my mom's, quite a few of them. And um, it's just this very simple service. And the music isn't that fantastic. It's just kind of there, there's some good music when they just stick to instrumental Celtic music, they're great, but the singing is not good. Um, and it's just kind of a ragged little congregation in some ways. But what happens every single Sunday is that people light candles as they say prayers for people they love and for themselves. I mean, we really do. We have this beautiful candlelighting part of the service. There's bread and wine, we know each other. There's this quiet Celtic music that's played, and there's a poem that's read. And I just sit there and and one of the things that I know is that all of the people who are there are there because they love God and they want to love their neighbors. And you know what, right now, to me, that's the the shining heart of the gospel. If I can be in a community of people who love God and are committed to loving their neighbors, and there's bread and wine and candlelight, some soft music, and people who care for each other. That's what more could you want? It's the it's actually the least boring thing in the world. And I have to this past week one of the men in the church, I don't know how old he is. He's he's about eighty, I would say, late 70s, maybe as as old as 82. And his best friend died. And after the service, after the regular ritual service, um, there was just this little note in the bulletin that said there would be a memorial read by him. And I thought, oh, well, we didn't really know her. So why is this happening? Well, he gets up and he tells this story about his friend, who actually had been a member of the church many years before but stopped going during COVID and never was able to come back. And um at the end of the of reading this this reminiscence, he was he he said, um, and in her honor, I just want to read this poem. And so he read Mary Oliver's poem that was written upon the death of her own life. And she said, When I die, I want to die as a bride, a bridegroom to amazement. And I don't want my life to have passed by without me knowing that I'd lived it. It's just a beautiful, beautiful, beautiful poem. And he read it with such heart. And yeah, the service had been dull, but the pastor is tired, she's working really hard. This old man gets up, he tells a story of this dear old friend of his who died and reads Mary Oliver, and we were all weeping. And it was such a surprise. It was just like the Holy Spirit just swept into that building and and and wrapped us all in shared grief, but not just for her, but I knew what we were feeling. We were feeling shared grief for the moment and for ourselves, and how sometimes we cut ourselves off from being the bridegrooms to amazement. And and yeah, you call that doll. And I say, you know, I feel really sad for you because you've had your sense of the spirit, I think, uh diminished um maybe by the tradition that you grew up in, but maybe they didn't teach you to open your eyes and your ears to be able to see and hear when amazement was right by, when love walked into the room and just said, You are loved, you are all loved, everyone is loved, God is loved. I I can't, I can't fault that. And and it hurts me. I have great empathy with people who have lost the ability to be able to see that because they've been locked in these systems that have muted their senses to that beauty of an 80-year-old man who's grieving his best friend.
SPEAKER_07Thank you for that. I feel like I can sense all the people that are listening and watching right now. I I can sense that there is something that that is maybe healing a little bit through this story.
SPEAKER_04I I I dream of that more than anything else. I'm not the person, not the mainliner who says, you know, we told you soul, or we're sorry that your parents were so, you know, stupid to follow this or whatever. I I that no. We all make decisions. Our parents make decisions. We often are doing exactly what we think is right, and we don't realize that we've stumbled into a world of pain and hurt, and where people do not have our best intentions. And so, so for me, my main feeling about this moment is not that I want to punish anybody. I want people to find a way back to their hearts. Um, because I think that that's the only way that we get out of this mess that we're in right now. If we do that, if all of us do that, find our way back to whatever that that place was that um the man in my congregation drew us all to, when we do that, maybe we can just right the wrongs that are being done right now and correct course and get get get on with a better, better journey.
SPEAKER_07Yeah. Well, I think we can do that by finishing with your book with a beautiful year. Um, this book, you know, I was listening to one of the most recent episodes of Communication Unscripted that you do with Jamar Tisbee and Robbie Jones and Kristen Covis Dumay. And it's just been a lifeline to me. Um, hearing you guys talk about news stories through your lenses has just been like, oh, I need to hear this. So thank you for that. What I heard you say is basically in the past, everybody didn't want to talk about religion and politics and church. And then you were like, I could talk about religion, politics, and church.
SPEAKER_06And now everybody wants to talk about religion, politics, and church. And you're like, I just want to talk about the Christian calendar and beauty.
SPEAKER_05Right. It's like crazy. I'm so tired of talking about religion and politics.
SPEAKER_07And so we're gonna do that. So I think we're just gonna end today on one of the most favorite things that I read in here. So this book, you modeled it after the Christian calendar. And um, growing up in the Evangelica tradition, um, we didn't really do any of that. Um, so like we had Advent, you know, need to go Easter. And so my poor Episcopal priest, um, like, you know, she always shows the thing to the kids and also is showing it to me. Like, here's what the Christian calendar is, here's where we are. And I'm like, okay, okay. So can you tell us a little bit about why you wrote this, why it's resonating in this moment?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, uh it's uh American Protestantism hasn't paid a whole lot of attention actually to the Christian year. It's just the more liturgical traditions, Catholics, Episcopalians, most Lutherans, um, and uh Eastern Orthodox. So there are other traditions that sort of pay attention, uh, mainline Presbyterians, some Methodists, etc. But it it's not um America is a very free church kind of place. So the Christian calendar is not something that people naturally know what it is, but but it's a it's a it's a a cycle of time that is very ancient. Um, it goes back to the very first centuries of of the church, and it's really a borrowing um at its origin from the Jewish calendar, uh, because our Jewish ancestors uh they had a calendar that was based on both the agricultural seasons and also lunar, uh, the phases of the moon. And so, like we when Christians celebrate Easter, why is it on a different day every year? It's because that's one of the oldest things on the Christian calendar, and it followed the lunar cycle that Passover was tied to in the Jewish community. And so, so we had this calendar that was a Jewish calendar. Most people were Jews, and what they started doing was plugging in Christian stories to the places. Pentecost is the same way. Uh, Pentecost was originally a Jewish holiday. Again, it varies every year. It was based on agricultural and lunar cycles. And so that was the first phase of the Christian calendar. As Christianity moved more into the mainstream in the Roman Empire, and lots of Romans uh became Christians, they began inserting different kinds of holidays, like Christmas. There was a Roman festival that was a very uh Bachian kind of wild frat party, essentially on uh December 25th. It was so bad that even the Romans were trying to control it and gotten that out of hand. And uh, so it was a celebration of the unconquerable sun, so a celebration of the sun, the actual sun, solar. And um Christians just said, okay, well, we don't want our people celebrating that. So what are we gonna do? Uh, we're gonna celebrate the unconquerable son of God. We're gonna put his birthday on that day because nobody knew what day Jesus was born on. And so Christmas Day became a celebration that Christians could have that challenged the Roman calendar, but also stole it, solar day. So eventually what happens in Western Christianity is we get this mishmash calendar that is part Jewish, part agricultural festival, and part Roman solar calendar. And now it's all filled in then with Christian stuff. But that calendar is just a different way of telling time. It's not linear, it's cyclical uh or spiral. It's definitely a circle where you just keep repeating. It starts around December 1st. This year it starts on November 29th. The first day of the Christian year is November 29th, which is the first Sunday of Advent. And that means it ends whatever the last day is before the first day it starts. So this year the Christian year ends on November 28th. And we walk into a new year, a full month before the secular calendar does. And that first month, that first season, Advent, is a season of waiting and anticipation that empire will be overturned and that the kingdom will be born in the world, the kingdom of God. And that reaches its culmination, of course, on Christmas Day. A 12-day celebration after Christmas. Hello, world. The 12 days of Christmas are December 25th through uh January 5th, not the 12 shopping days before. And so that celebration of Christmas hinges into the new year. The Christian year does not have a celebration of New Year's Day other than a feast called the Feast of the Holy Name, which is celebrated on January 1st, seven days after quote unquote the birth of Jesus, when Jesus would have been named in the temple. So it's an entirely different way of looking at a time. And it's so cool. And um, I've discovered over the years that it's one of the spiritual practices and the most ancient of spiritual tools that grounds my life. And it also gives me a sense of real spiritual power to be able to understand how the story that the Christian year tells is a story about resistance to empire.
SPEAKER_07Amen. Well, we'll go ahead and uh open to Jesus Opens Minds. This is in the Easter section, page 202. Then Jesus opened their minds, Luke 24, 45. In the last few decades, most mainline Protestant denominations rolled out branding mottos, God's work, our hands, ELCA, the Episcopal Church welcomes you, Episcopal Church, and God is still speaking, UCC. These pithy theological phrases communicate their central messages of doing justice, offering hospitality and spiritual exploration. While the slogans are good and articulate core values in their churches, I've always thought the Methodists came up with the best of the lot. Open hearts, open minds, open doors. To be open is a good thing. In psychology, openness, a capacity of receptivity to new ideas and experiences, is a personality trait highly correlated with well-being, especially curiosity, creativity, and happiness. Openness is an important social concept too. We live in an age of open networks, open sources, open education, open information, open AI, and open access. Indeed, some social scientists argue that open organizing is one of the primary principles of our times. While we might argue about what can and should be considered in the domain of openness, there isn't much argument that ours is a world where the quest for openness across all areas of human experience is pressuring borders, boundaries, and walls of all sorts. An open society prizes inclusion, transparency, collaboration, and community. Even the most hardcore wall builder knows the pain of a closed society. Remember the COVID lockdown, remember when everything was closed. It was awful. Somewhat ironically, those who mostly reject the idea of an open society hated the lockdown, really hated it. Closure was so painful for people not noted for openness that they refuse to cooperate. People who love boundaries and want to build walls and keep others out. They had to open things up, even if just for themselves. Because even those who resist openness yearn for it at some level, in some way. Openness, another way of speaking of freedom, is a deep human longing. How great was it when the closed signs were finally taken down and replaced by open. On the third Sunday of Easter, we read yet another story where Jesus miraculously appeared among his disciples. The disciples are huddled together, isolated in a small group, fearful of reports that Jesus was alive. The men didn't believe the women and their tale of an empty tomb. As Luke remarked of the woman's report, but these words seemed to them an idle tale. That sounds a lot like the Easter reading from the Gospel of John. Indeed, tradition holds, and scholars argue, that both Luke and John were telling the story of Easter night when Jesus appeared to his terrifying friends behind the locked doors of the upper room and said, Peace be with you. In John's account, peace seemed to melt the disciples' anxieties. In effect, their hearts opened to embrace what and who they feared. Those fears were external, the people whom they had locked out and internal, what they feared in themselves. Jesus's peace, the breath of God, carried away the fears that closed them in. And they responded with emotional freedom. Then the disciples rejoiced. In Luke's telling, however, some skeptics remain in the crowd, just saying peace didn't do it for them. They remained startled and terrified, close to the possibility that Jesus was anything other than a ghost. Peace didn't work. So Jesus calmly showed them his hands and feet as bodily proof of life and then added, Have you anything to eat? The Lord of the universe was hungry after having been executed, spending a day in Hades and being raised from the dead. Watching Jesus chow down broiled fish, evidently convinced the unbelievers in that group. Then after all that, he opened their minds. On the night of the resurrection, Jesus didn't insist that they believe what he wanted them to believe. He didn't give them a doctrine test. He opened their minds. The intellectual stone rolled away. They were no longer closed to the possibility that the women had told the truth. When their minds opened, their fears receded. They opened to creativity, imagination, and transformation. Easter is a story of resurrection. And the two subsequent Sundays unfold its meaning with these twinned stories about openness. John, the disciples are so afraid that they lock themselves behind closed doors. The room in the story signifies the double meaning of spiritual interiority, the heart. They locked the doors of their hearts. Jesus showed up, spoke peace to them, and opened their hearts. Luke, the disciples appeared. Be in the same place, not only fearful but perplexed and confused by the day's events. Jesus showed up and extended peace. Yet this scared them even more. Why are you frightened? And why do doubts arise in your hearts? That fear obscured their ability to understand. So Jesus showed them his hands and feet. This moved their hearts. But Luke added, While in their joy, they were disbelieving and still wondering. And Jesus ate most likely with them. Only after that strange meal, he opened their minds to understand the scriptures. John, open hearts, Luke, open minds. Open hearts and open minds that can open doors. Believing a resurrection happened doesn't mean much. If we lock ourselves behind closed doors, nurse our fears, and wall off our neighbors, it doesn't mean much to closed hearts and closed minds. What if resurrection means opening the heart to radical joy? What if it means sitting at a table and eating with those whom we assume dead? And at the table we discover that those we left to the grave are as fully human as we are. What if it means experiencing and understanding the world with imagination and possibility? What if it means that we both feel differently and think differently? What if it is like moving from locking down to opening up, from fear to love? It infuriates me when Christians insist that one must assent to a particular creed or singular theological definition of resurrection to follow Jesus. They've done the very thing that both John and Luke warned against. Putting boundaries around the resurrection itself by insisting on precise doctrinal parameters. That's being closed-minded. If you turn the resurrection into a tomb, you're doing it the wrong way. Resurrection is openness to the wild, unpredictable, confusing, puzzling, unbelievable, and terrifying tale of the women. The tomb is empty, Jesus lives, open hearts, open minds, the veil is rent, every wall torn down, every boundary dissolved, every lock broken, every door thrown off as hinges, as Apollon says in Galatians 3.28 that there is no longer Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male and female. We humans long for such openness, open hearts, open minds, open doors. That's it. That's the story. There's not much else one can say when it comes to following Jesus, except perhaps a piece. Oh, and would you pass me some of that broiled fish? Can you give a little commentary on this section?
SPEAKER_04Well, I was really taken um when I was working on this book. I was reading all the texts that are traditionally associated with the post-Easter accounts of Jesus. And so in the same way that Christmas is 12 days after Christmas, Easter is Easter Sunday, and then 50 days after after Easter. So it lasts a really long time. And there are very traditional stories that are told and retold uh in the midst of this part of the cycle. And one of them is uh this account from uh Jew uh from Luke, uh Luke 24, and it literally says, then Jesus opened their minds, and I just laughed when I read that line, and it just sort of really stood out to me uh because we often think that faith is about closing your mind. Uh, but in this particular story of Jesus and the and the apostles, is that um they were unwilling to believe the possibility of resurrection, and they were certainly unwilling to believe the women who were telling them the story. And yet it says that then Jesus opened their minds. And so what that whole chapter is is a play off of that phrase and how uh being a person of faith, trusting in Jesus, um, and and understanding what the deep truths are of the resurrection is not a way of checking yourself behind closed doors, but it's a way of walking into um a spacious place where possibilities you never imagined are actually present. And that's what happens to the disciples here. And I I make a whole riff on that out of the fact that um that one of the denominations we've talked about uh quite a bit um in this conversation, uh, they were trying to come up with a branding thing, doing the one thing the mainliners cannot do well because somebody told them trying to help.
SPEAKER_06That's that's where I'm that's part of my work.
SPEAKER_04That's right. Just try, you know, some marketing consultant was trying to help them. And the the Methodist church, the United Methodist Church, there's two Methodist churches. The Global Methodist Church is the one that is not as open-minded, but the United Methodist Church is the the more spacious one. Um, and so anyway, the United Methodist Church came up with this slogan, open hearts, open minds, and open doors. And uh so I just I just love that. I thought to myself, of all the branding slogans I've read for a mainline church, that one is the most gospel. Open hearts, open minds, open doors. And that's a pretty good um description of the way that I understand um the gospel.
SPEAKER_07Diana, the book is a beautiful year and it's out everywhere now. Um, I want to thank you so much. Where can people find you? I'm just gonna start by saying the cottage on Substack. Um, you and Sarah Bessie, and is it Jen Hatmaker? I think you guys are like the top Nadia Boltzweber.
SPEAKER_04Oh, and Nadia, and Nadia Boltzweber. Yeah. And Jen, uh, there's a a number of very uh well-known and progressive Christian women who are at the top of the leaderboard all the time in Substack. And it's so funny to think that because we're not really kind of the marketing types. People just like our writing and that we've sort of developed these lovely audiences who want to hear what we have to say. And so I love writing uh the cottage. I've done it for now six years, and um, the influence that it's had has amazed me. And also the stories that people tell me as a result of things they've read, or the way that my words have encouraged them is just I mean, it's so humbling. It's it's such an incredible gift. Um, and so when I feel like I want to quit, I just remember um that there are people who are waiting to hear the voice that I put in the world and that that helps them uh find that more spacious uh faith. So the cottage on Substack, that's my main social media place right now. I do post some on Blue Sky. I have an ex account, but I only have it to protect my name so that nobody steals my name and pretends to be me. So don't try to go there and and join me there. I hardly post a thing. I'm on Facebook, I do post a little bit over there, but I'm kind of really mad right now at them. I worry about their affection for AI. Substack has AI detectors, and uh you will legitimately know which authors use AI, which ones don't, how much different people use AI. They're trying to create a moderate culture of acceptable AI use on Substack. I do not use AI except for just pure uh occasional research possibilities. All the words are are mine, they are nobody else's. So yeah, we're all trying to just kind of make our way through this new technological moment. And I try to stay away from MAGA as much as possible.
SPEAKER_07I hear you. Well, we'll have you back on at some point. And, you know, we actually got through this whole episode without really talking about MAGA and it's kind of nice, you know? Yeah, it is. I envision a future. I think about this period will be over, this moment will be over. And when people look up and look around, kind of like at the end of like an epic Avengers movie, you know, and everyone just kind of looks up and goes, what do we do now? I think there are people like you who have been laying the groundwork and the foundation for beauty, for connection, and for paths forward that I think people are on board with. So I want to thank you for coming today to the Sacred Slope.
SPEAKER_04Well, thank you for having me. I really appreciate it. And I'm grateful we didn't talk about MAGA because I've been warning about Christian nationalism for 20 years, and I'm just tired of it. Um, but what I'm not tired of is talking about all the things we shared today.
SPEAKER_07Thank you for joining us today on the Sacred Slope. If you'd like to nominate a pastor, priest, or clergy member anywhere in the world, send me an email at alexis at the sacred slope.com. Music was by Brett Rutledge, Eddie Irvin, and Sean Spence. May the fruit of the spirit guide you this week. I'm Alexis Rice. Go in peace, friends. Oh, and if you like this content, make sure to follow the Sacred Slope on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, Threads, TikTok, and Blue Sky at the Sacred Slope. You can watch on YouTube or Spotify, and you can listen on Apple and everywhere you get your podcast. Until next time.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The New Evangelicals Podcast
Hosted by Tim Whitaker
The Tim & April Show
The New Evangelicals
Data Over Dogma
Daniel McClellan and Daniel Beecher
Recovering Evangelicals
Luke Jeffrey Janssen
The Holy Post
Phil Vischer
Pivot
New York Magazine
The Curiosity Shop with Brené Brown and Adam Grant
Vox Media Podcast Network
Unlocking Us with Brené Brown
Vox Media Podcast Network
The Bible For Normal People
Peter Enns and Jared Byas
And Also With You
The Reverend Lizzie McManus-Dail, The Reverend Laura Di Panfilo
Reclaiming My Theology
Brandi Miller
Holy Heretics: Losing Religion and Finding Jesus
The Sophia Society
Learning How to See with Brian McLaren
Center for Action and Contemplation
VeggieTales: Very Veggie Silly Stories
Big Idea Entertainment
The Evolving Faith Podcast
Evolving Faith
Another Name For Every Thing with Richard Rohr
Center for Action and Contemplation
Religion on the Mind
Dan Koch
The Ezra Klein Show
New York Times Opinion
Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov
Vox Media Podcast Network