The Sacred Slope
Where the slippery slope becomes sacred ground.
For the spiritually tender — those searching for healthier expressions of our global Christian faith and deconstructing harmful theology.
Listen to conversations with pastors, priests, reverends, scholars, artists, and public voices from multiple denominations, cultures, backgrounds, and genders.
Come to be challenged, healed, and begin again.
The Sacred Slope
61. Lisa Sharon Harper (Episcopal) | White Supremacy, Evangelicalism & Decolonizing Christianity
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
61. Lisa Sharon Harper (Episcopal) | White Supremacy, Evangelicalism & Decolonizing Christianity
What if the Christianity many Americans are deconstructing isn’t Christianity itself-but a version shaped by whiteness, empire, and power?
Lisa Sharon Harper is a public theologian, author, activist, playwright, founder and president of FreedomRoad, and is currently discerning ordination in the Episcopal Church.
Lisa traces the complicated history of American evangelicalism—from the Black church and abolitionist movements to fundamentalism, the Southern Baptist Convention, segregation, and the modern political power of white evangelicalism.
Then she challenges one of the central ideas of modern faith deconstruction:
Christianity was never a white faith.
Jesus and the earliest Christians emerged from colonized people in the ancient Near East. Lisa argues that abandoning Christianity because of white Christian racism can leave the supremacy of Western Christianity itself uninterrogated.
She doesn’t call us to deconstruct Christianity.
She calls us to decolonize it.
We explore Acts 2, implicit bias, the Black church, fundamentalism, Christian nationalism, religious certainty-and what happens when we rediscover Jesus outside the version of Christianity we inherited.
Lisa leaves us with three words:
“Seek brown Jesus.”
✨ GUEST + FOLLOW
Lisa Sharon Harper (Episcopal) IG: @lisasharper
Founder & President, FreedomRoad @freedomroad.us
📚 MENTIONED + RESOURCES
Christena Cleveland (PhD) — IG: @christenacleveland
Rev. Dr. David P. Gushee — IG: @d_pgushee
Rev. Dr. Kelly Brown Douglas — IG: @revdrkbd
Sojourners — Independent Christian magazine exploring faith, culture, politics & social justice.
📖 Lisa’s 2015 essay that opens this episode:
“Four Easy Ways to Be a White Supremacist”
https://sojo.net/magazine/septemberoctober-2015/four-easy-ways-be-white-supremacist
📰 Explore Sojourners: @sojogram
https://sojo.net
⛪ THE SACRED SLOPE LABS
Three virtual labs, 2 options per lab, open to everyone, everywhere. Attend one, two, or all three.
LAB 1: I Thought This Was Christianity
📅 October 22 & 23
LAB 2: Who Formed Us?
📅 November 5 & 6
LAB 3: Speaking Across the Faith Divide
📅 November 12 & 13
🎟️ Register: thesacredslope.com
🥚 Listen all the way through for an Easter egg revealing our first guest speaker for Lab 1.
⏱️ EPISODE CHAPTERS
02:42 — White Supremacy: Explicit vs. Implicit Bias
09:56 — Meet Lisa Sharon Harper
12:23 — PhD in Womanist Ethics
18:56 — Evangelical ≠ Republican or Democrat
21:48 — What Does “Evangelical” Mean?
28:00 — The Black Church & Second Great Awakening
32:43 — Slaveholder Faith & American Christianity
36:38 — What’s Behind “Non-Denominational”?
41:36 — Should We Save Evangelicalism?
44:00 — Fundamentalism & Certainty
45:23 — What Happens After Deconstruction?
47:06 — Christianity Was Never a White Faith
52:51 — Decolonizing Acts 2
55:47 — “I’m Not for Deconstructing. I’m for Decolonizing.”
57:13 — “Seek Brown Jesus”
57:20 — Sacred Slope Labs + Easter Egg
#LisaSharonHarper #DecolonizingChristianity #Deconstruction #Evangelicalism #ChristianNationalism
About The Sacred Slope
thesacredslope.com
Where the slippery slope becomes sacred ground.
For the spiritually tender - raised in or rooted in Christianity.
Come explore our global, diverse, inclusive Christian faith, deconstruction, and spiritual identity in a rapidly changing world. Through conversations with clergy, scholars, and cultural voices, the show creates space for people navigating faith after certainty, church harm, or political co-option of religion.
🎧 WATCH: YouTube / Spotify
LISTEN: Apple Podcasts + everywhere
FOLLOW: @thesacredslope (IG, FB, Threads, TikTok, YouTube, Bluesky)
🔗 Connect
🎧 Explore episodes & community: linktr.ee/TheSacredSlope
🎙 Hosted by Alexis Rice
🎵 Music by Brett Rutledge, Eddie Irvin & Sean Spence
📬 Nominate a guest: alexis@thesacredslope.com
🌿 Community Guidelines 🌿
Fruit of the Spirit: ❤️ love • 💫 joy • ☮️ peace • 🕊 patience • 💝 kindness • 🌿 goodness • 🙏 faithfulness • 🤲 gentleness • 💪 self-control
I got into it back and forth with this group of white deconstructionists who were talking about how they needed to, you know, basically throw bab Jesus out with the bathwater, like throw the baby out with the bathwater. And I told them, I was like, you realize, right? If you throw out Jesus, if you say, uh, you know, I'm not down with this Jesus, with this Christian thing because they're racist, because that was the main reason why they were saying they're racist, which let's be real, many of them are, then you are actually just showing you have been captured by white supremacy. And you you are white supremacist. Because you have to understand that this faith that you are ditching because of white people's racism was not a white faith. It actually is a faith born in Afro-Asia, the Levant. Um it is a people group who, in fact, um just recently I had I did a podcast with Christina Cleveland, who has a really great book out now called The Black Madonna. And so she's looked at, you know, the images of Mary, like forevermore, like from the beginning to now. And she confirmed that all of the images of all of the people in scripture, for the first 300 years of the Christian faith, they were all black and brown.
SPEAKER_01Wow.
SPEAKER_06All of the images of Jesus and Mary and Paul and Peter, all of the images until Constantine were black and brown. So this is not a white faith. It's a black and brown, indigenous, colonized, serially enslaved faith. And so when you throw out that baby with the bathwater, saying I'm not going to be Christian because I don't want to be racist, or Christian equals racist. No, no, you're just responding out of your own white supremacy because if you did one iota of work, you would find, or you would actually even just be able to think about it, these people were brown and they were colonized at the time. Maybe what they had to say, maybe what Jesus had to say, maybe even what Paul even had to say, was not going to be something that would further entrench their enslavement, further entrench their colonized status.
SPEAKER_04Welcome to the Sacred Slope, where the slippery slope becomes sacred ground. I'm Alexis Rice, and before we get into today's conversation, I want to start with something that Lisa Sharon Harper wrote more than a decade ago. This piece is from Sojourners, and it's called Four Easy Ways to Be a White Supremacist. And it was published in September of 2015. I want you to remember that as I read this. 2015, before the 2016 election, before Charlottesville, before George Floyd, before January 6th, before Christian nationalism became part of our everyday political vocabulary. And reading Lisa's words now, more than a decade later, I keep thinking she was trying to get us to see something. As a public theologian, an activist, a playwright, an author, and a founder and president of Freedom Road, I think it's so important that we continue to listen to voices like Lisa's. This is from Sojourner September, October of 2015. Four easy ways to be a white supremacist. At its heart, white supremacy is not about white hoods and burning crosses. Even as Southern states and GOP candidates jumped through hoops to distance themselves from the Confederate flag, a backlash erupted among those claiming the flag was merely a symbol of, quote, heritage. Battle flag waving Southerners and Confederacy sympathizers seemed to leap at the opportunity to wave their banner high. But what about the rest of us? One of the most profound statements I've heard recently came from Reverend Jin Kim, founding pastor of Church of All Nations in Minnesota. This Korean-born pastor stood at the podium of the Sojourner Summit and said with conviction, I am a white supremacist. How can this man, a person of color, who's dedicated his life to ethnic and cultural reconciliation, be a white supremacist, the same way any of us can? After all, at its heart, white supremacy is not about white hoods, battle flags, and burning crosses. These symbols are what we call explicit bias. People know when they are practicing it. But most often, white supremacy is about implicit bias that favors whiteness. It's about the unconscious associations that we make in our minds before we even know we've done it. White, rich, black, poor, white, good, black, bad, white, trustworthy, black, scary. You get the idea. These are the unconscious biases that shape the way we order our lives, the communities we live in, the places we shop, the churches we attend, the leadership from others we accept or reject, and the policies we support or don't. It's not hard to fume at the thought of the killer of Mother Emmanuel's nine, and it feels good to click like and share posts calling for the removal of Confederate flags. But if we stop there, bias beats us. It is the unconscious biases of the masses that keep us from moving forward, not the explicit biases of the few. So check out this tongue-in-cheek list of four easy ways to be a white supremacist, regardless of your own race. One, plan a conference on church planting with a speaker lineup so white it would make honey boo-boo blush. And if you want to increase your quote diversity, have one speaker of color, even if he is from India, an Amish MC, and maybe a black worship leader. Two, make references to theologians, historians, or leaders when their foundation is Western theology, the history of Western civilization, or leadership of a white community. But when referring to a person of color, reference them as a quote black theologian, quote Latino historian, or quote Asian leader. Three, envision Jesus as a white person who speaks with a King James accent. Four, live in a mostly white private community, place your kids in mostly white schools, or go to a mostly white church and work in a mostly white office. Then, when a black colleague or friend on Facebook hosts about Black Lives Matter, accuse him or her of playing the race card. A 2014 report from the Kirwan Institute identifies a few key things we can do to dismantle the craziness. Here are four. One, take the free Harvard implicit association test online. Two, grow your empathy. Seriously listen to the stories of people who are not white. Read what they write, watch movies by them about them. Three, deepen relationships with people who are not white. The Cure One report reveals that when folks build relationships with people they were biased against, their unconscious bias levels go down. Four, take every thought captive. Focusing on a person's unique traits as opposed to their group affiliation lowers implicit bias scores. When I'm talking with people who I'm tempted to write off as, quote, just a fill-in-the-blink, I look them in the eyes if I can and remember that the image of God lives inside them. And I sit in that truth. Together, let's kick bias's butt. Ready for the show? All right, let's go.
SPEAKER_06We will be the founders of a new America. I've actually been saying, we are about to come into a new America. We are not going back. We're not going, we are not gonna be able to go back to what we had. We will not go back to what we had because what we had got us to where we are, and we will not do this again. We just won't. We're not gonna do this again. So we have an opportunity in this moment, in this clearing of a moment, to dream, architect, build something new, a new way of being together in the world. Do you hear me? Talk to me in the chat if you hear me. Do you hear what I am saying? We have an opportunity to be architects of a new America. But we can't do that from the sidelines. We have to do that from the front lines. And so that means getting out there. It doesn't mean everybody has to march, but it means everybody has to play a part in that short-term thing that she was talking about. Are you a communications person? Are you an economics person? Are you gonna be dealing with the laws? Are you going to be dealing with the voter registration get out, the freedom summer that's necessary? Are you the person to organize that? Whatever you are doing is what is whatever you are doing, you have to leverage it in this moment. For this moment, for the architecting of the new America.
SPEAKER_04Welcome back to the Sacred Slope, friends, where the slippery slope becomes sacred ground. I'm Alexis Rice, and today I am so excited because we have Lisa Sharon Harper. Hi, Lisa.
SPEAKER_06Hi, Alexis. Good to see you here.
SPEAKER_04And actually good to be meet your community here. Thank you so much for being with us. I can't wait for everyone to see you and hear from you and just the beauty and the wisdom that I know we're gonna have in this conversation. I'd love to tell people a little bit about you. Most people are going to know about you. You know, something that's funny. When I look at um guests, I'd love to have on the show, I often do it by, you know, the number of people that I'm following that are following someone else. And you have like the most people that I'm following that are following you. Um yeah, like scholars, theologians, pastors, PhDs, and a lot of them look to you and your wisdom. And I was like, I've got to talk to Lisa. So I'm very excited to do that.
SPEAKER_06Well, I'm totally honored and I'm grateful. I'm grateful people are listening and following. Thank you.
SPEAKER_04Lisa Sharon Harper is a public theologian, author, activist, playwright, and the founder and president of Freedom Road, where she has spent years helping communities confront what she calls the narrative gap, the stories we inherit about who we are, how we got here, and what repair requires. She has an MFA in playwriting from USC, a master's degree in human rights from Columbia University, and she's currently pursuing her PhD in womanist ethics at the Freie Universiteit in Amsterdam. Is that right? Yes, and I love that you actually pronounced it better than me.
SPEAKER_06And also, you should also know I'm in the process of discerning ordination with the Episcopal Church in the US.
SPEAKER_04Wonderful! Yeah. I've been in the Episcopal Church the last seven years and coming from evangelical megachurch culture and then to Presbyterian, I have found home in the Episcopal Church. So I'm I'm so thrilled to hear that.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, yeah, I am too. I mean, I actually have a meeting with my ordination committee tonight. So I'm very much on the top of my mind right now. So thank you.
SPEAKER_04That's awesome. Oh, okay. As I mentioned to you before we started recording, I've lived in the Netherlands and I lived in Amsterdam. My husband's Dutch. So I I know the Freij Universiteit. So I was like, So tell, can you tell people a little bit about why you chose this specific um PhD program if people are interested for themselves?
SPEAKER_06Well, absolutely. One of the things that I learned when I was researching how to get a PhD or what's most important, you know, when you're doing a master's degree, usually the thing that's most important is the program itself, right? Like the program, you know, what its ranking is or where it is, what university. What they say about a PhD is what's most important is who is your advisor. And so years ago, years ago, like literally 15 years ago or so, I approached David Gushy to ask, hey, you know, do you lead PhD students? I would love to study under you. Because he was doing a lot of the same kind of work that I was doing at the time, like public ethics, especially. And he said, Oh, you know, I'm not, I don't lead PhD students, but you know, I'm coming up on a time when I might. So keep in touch and da da da da. So, like literally like 10 years goes by, and I had not pursued it. You know, I looked into it a little bit, da-da-da-da-da, but didn't go anywhere. And then I ended up on a panel with him about a month after I had this breakthrough experience listening to Kelly Brown Douglas speak. To despair.
SPEAKER_02For despair, perhaps even more than fear, is the soil in which oppressive and authoritarian regimes take root and thrive. Despair paralyzes, it convinces us that nothing will ever change, and before we know it, we began to compromise, to comply and to concede. We settle for silence, we go along to get along, and slowly, even unwittingly, we lose sight of our values, our moral bearings, even losing sight of who and whose we are. It is no accident that despair is being cultivated in this our time. Through relentless untruths, through ceaseless distractions, through calculated chaos and deliberate scapegoating, we are borne down and told that to protest is foolish and futile, unpatriotic, and even seditious. We are told implicitly and explicitly that silence is safer. We are told that compliance is wisdom and that nothing we do will matter. And yet, precisely because we are living in such despairing times, this moment demands something of us. This moment requires of us something as individuals, as people of faith, as children of God, as those who dare to carry forth the legacy of Martin Luther King Jr. We are required to do something. And so we must ask again with urgency and honesty, what are we to learn from Martin Luther King Jr. as we remember him in these our despairing times.
SPEAKER_04Thank you for joining us today on the Sacred Slope. If you'd like to nominate a pastor, priest, or clergy member anywhere in the world, send me an email at alexis at the sacred slope.com. Music was by Brett Rutledge, Eddie Irvin, and Sean Spence. May the fruit of the Spirit guide you this week. I'm Alexis Rice. Go in peace, friends.
SPEAKER_06So Kelly Brown Douglas is this amazing womanist scholar who was really among those original womenist um scholars that came up in the 1980s. She was literally in that same cohort with Katie Cannon and and um and others. And so I was at a conference where she was speaking, and I had been wondering, even then, I was like, should I get my PhD? Oh, I don't know. People are telling me you don't really have to because you're doing the same stuff that PhD people, what they get the PhD to be able to do, you're writing, da-da-da-da. And so I went in to this conference with these questions in the back recesses of my mind. And then she tells this story about her son, who was really struggling or really struggled to get through undergrad. And his counselor told him, Oh, you know, undergrad's not for everybody, you know, just go out and find a vocation, you know, and whatever. And he went to his mom and he said, and this is Kelly Brown Douglas, by the way, she's like one of the deans of the National Cathedral, okay? So he says, he says to her, Mom, you know, my counselor says that education is not for everybody. What do you think? And she said, son, get your degree and put it in your back pocket. You don't have to know why you need it, but when you need it, you'll have it. And I was like, That's it. That's it. That was for me. That was for me. So I met, I you know, I had that like aha moment. I now know I need to get my PhD. And then one month later, I'm on a panel with David Gushy. And, you know, in between panel sessions, because we were on a couple of them, um, I told him, I was like, I now know, I am definitely gonna be getting my PhD. Are you leading students now? And he said, Lisa, are you serious about this? Because I just signed with the universiteit, you know. Um uh he had just signed and he was gonna be one of the leaders of their theology program and ethics program. And I was like, what? And he said, if you want this, I can make it happen quick. I was like, oh my god. So I mean, literally within a week, I had submitted my application and within a couple of weeks I was in. And um Wow. Yeah. So the the way that I'm doing it though is not directly through um Frey University, it's actually through IBTS, International Baptist Theological Studies Center, which is a group that helps mostly Eastern Europeans, actually, and also some South Asians, and actually a whole cohort of Americans as well, to go through the PhD process at Free University, at University Dayton. So I'm doing it through IBTS, and it's been a really great experience so far. I'm closing year three going into year four.
SPEAKER_04Going into year four. Incredible. I love to hear that. Thank you. I know that's gonna help somebody somewhere considering getting a PhD. Then we have to talk about your books. Your books include Evangelical Does Not Equal Republican or Democrat. Can you just a little intro to that one for those who have never read it?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_06Evangelical Does Not Equal Republican or Democrat was my very first book ever. Well, the first book after my plays, because I had actually written a play that was published by um Samuel French Play Publishing Company and pushed the wind down. One, the National Kennedy Center and American Kennedy Center American College Theater Festival of 1996. So it's like dating myself. But the first actual book book, not play, was that one. They came to me to say, hey, would you be interested in writing this book? And so I said, yeah. And so I had to submit a proposal for what I would do with it. And their original title was Evangelical Does Not Equal Republican. But I wasn't interested in that. I wanted it to be it doesn't equal Republican or Democrat. And um, so what it ended up being is not a political book at all. Actually, what it was was a book about what does it mean to be evangelical. And um, and you know, what are some of the big markers of evangelicalism? Well, race is a big one because evangelicals were uh, you know, at least the mythology is that they were at the forefront, and in many ways they were at the forefront of the abolitionist movement in the 19th century and even the late 18th century. But even that started through the black church. The black church was evangelical. So um when you talk about evangelicals today, it's just a whole different thing. It is just not the same. They're just not the same, they're not even really the same people. Um in the 20th century, you had a movement of fundamentalism that came up in the really beginning of the 20th century, mid-20th century, they started to say, you know, we want to legitimate ourselves, so we're gonna go back to college, we're gonna write and we're gonna research, and we're gonna call ourselves no longer fundamentalists, we're gonna call ourselves evangelicals. So there's that strain as well, and that's the strain that has gone MAGA over the last several years. It never, in many ways, was never not MAGA. That's the strain that was anti-black, that's the strain that actually had literally in Red Summer, they were the ones who caused race riots all over the Midwest and the South and had picnics at lynchings. I mean, that was literally that strain, the fundamentalist strain that then became evangelical.
SPEAKER_04And I'd like to just clarify here, those were Christians doing this to other folks, correct? So those people were self-declaring Christians. Right.
SPEAKER_06Those were people who said they were Christians who were killing Christians. Yes. Thank you.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So this brings up something I've never asked on the show, and I'm curious about it. You have such a global understanding of the world and evangelical. And I do want to ask you about this world. Word evangelical in this time. People have wondered like, do we abandon it? Do we reclaim it? Typically, because evangelical fundamentalism, conservative Christian MAGA, it's kind of all goes together in the United States, but it can mean very different things, right? I was speaking when we just went to Wild Goose to the um bishop of Iceland. They're from the Evangelical Lutheran Church, the Church of Iceland, right? That means something very different. They're queer inclusion and they have a women in leadership and all these things. So what are your thoughts?
SPEAKER_06Well, I would say, so Charles Finney developed the altar call. And when we think of evangelicals, we think of the altars, right? We think of going down and kneeling and, you know, doing kind of penance and then coming up from that altar a different person, right? Getting saved. Transformation, being, yeah, saved at the altar. And I mean, for me, I grew up not going to church. I grew up not really having very much connection to it at all. I I mean, I wondered who was God. I wondered what was prayer, who was Jesus, just because you just wonder those things. I actually didn't even know Jesus. I thought Luke was the main man in the Bible because that's the name of the church we did go to when we went to church, St. Luke. I was baptized at St. Luke's church, right? And so I thought, oh, he's the main man. Um, so but what I found um over the course of my teenage years, I was introduced to Jesus at a down in Cape May, New Jersey, and um really lovely communities, um, very small Wesleyan church, really took me under their wing one year and just discipled me. Like they poured into me. And I was able to ask all my questions through their youth group. I started going to their youth group. And but I came to their youth group through the community-wide youth group, which was Young Life. And um, they called it Why. And, you know, to this day, I think I now know it was the it was Young Life because they did the whole, you know, goldfish thing, eating goldfish and all that. Um, and it was fun and all that. But um in that space, that's where I really met Jesus, like the person of Jesus and the Bible, and was taught how to pray and and what prayer is and all of that. And so I when I came to faith um on August 21st, 1983, at a Sunday evening camp church meeting at a campground, beach, I think it's Beach Comber Campground in um in Cape May, uh circa 8:30 p.m., maybe 9 p.m., um, went forward at the altar. My life really did change. It was actual, like a real change. Um uh it felt like a spiritual weight had been lifted from my body. And but I also was told very quickly that I needed to vote for Reagan, even though I was only 14 years old. Wow. How am I gonna vote for anybody, right? So, but they were told me very quickly, but it wasn't like the adults, it was actually my teenage friends who told me I needed to be a Republican. And so I went home and I got a tract right outside of church that told me Mondale was actually uh running for president at the time, 1984, against Reagan. And the tract told me that if Mondale wins, he is the Antichrist, and um all the little children are gonna be rounded up and put into work camps. I swear to you, it said that.
unknownWow.
SPEAKER_06I I ran home and I told my sister and who was my little sister, and she cried and she was telling mom, mom, you have to vote for Reagan. And I was like, Mom, you have to vote for Reagan, and she said, Who are you and what have you done with my child? And um, so my path to where I am now is very long and windy. We don't need to know the whole path. But just know that the faith that we carry as evangelicals has a heritage that stretches back past the United States. Evangelicalism actually stems from the 1600s in Europe, northern Europe, you know, Germany, Switzerland, all of that. And in that space, there were decisions that were made. There were like rogue, in some ways you might call them anarchists now. They were saying no to the establishment. J. Cameron Carter actually talks, he talks about the ark, as in the way that we think about the world and the foundational assumptions of the world. Well, the foundational assumptions of the world at that time were the Catholic structure and the Lutheran structure. But this evangelical thing, it really hadn't come to be yet. And they started to say, no, we need to actually have direct access to God. So they democratized faith. The evangelical movement of the 1600s, the 17th century, was a democratizing force. It was one that actually said, all individuals are valuable. Like there was something really powerful and beautiful about what it did in Europe at that time. But it also, when it came to the United States, it was blended with Puritanism. The Puritanism, it blended this democratizing power with the most important value within the Puritans was to be pure. And purity in a racialized society then translated into people who are not white as snow are impure. And the racial hierarchy was fueled in part by that, not at all, fully by that, but in part, yes. So evangelicalism on US soil has always been a mixed bag. The black church actually was the catalyst for the second great awakening in the United States. The black church had an anarchic moment. I'm reading this book by James Cameron Carter, and I'm really struck by his um idea that black faith is anarchic faith. It actually is faith that breaks out of the prescribed, proscribed structures of faith that came to us from Europe. And so, and that's what happened with the Black Church. And I go to that very first, like major stream of black faith, um, St. Thomas's um church here in Philadelphia, Absalom Jones's Church, which was formed out of that very first walkout that happened in eight 1787, the same year, and just a block away from where they were writing the Constitution. And many of the people who were writing the Constitution went to St. George's Church. And Absalom Jones and Richard Allen were like deacons at this church. And their congregation, the black congregation, was larger than the white one. And they were forced to sit up in the galleries, which if you go, you can see it. It's dangerous. It really dangerous. And they weren't allowed to kneel at the altar. And so they said, Yes, they were not allowed to kneel at the altar, nor were they even allowed to kneel in the galleries because Absalom Jones tried to kneel in the gallery, and a white usher came and tried to muscle him up and like not let him kneel. And he took his cane out and basically got into it almost a fight with this guy. And they were just like, they stood up and they said, peace out. And that was the end. That was or that was the beginning of the black church. It was a protest movement against the corruption of faith within white and whiteified churches, right? So um racialized faith. And so my church began out of protest. And that actually is the beginning of the Second Great Awakening, literally. So when Charles Finney then develops that altar call, he doesn't just develop it out of the blue, he's developing it in the context of a slave ocracy. And it was their their foundational belief in the 19th century that the society was corrupt, that slavery, the institution of slavery itself, had corrupted society.
SPEAKER_04Yes.
SPEAKER_06So what Charles Finney and others like um Harriet Beecher Stowe and Sojourner Truth, they all like spoke on the same circuit. Um, they would they would preach that we have to get clean as a society. We have to get clean. And so he would call people forward to the altar to get clean. And so, in order to complete that cleaning of our society, signup sheets for the abolitionist movement were close by the altar. And if you talk to some people, they'll say it was on the altar. But signup sheets for the abolitionist movement was part of what it meant to be an evangelical in that second great awakening. My own ancestors, uh I believe, benefited from that second great awakening. They were enslaved on the slave schedule. Henry Lawrence and his brothers were enslaved on the slave schedule in 1850, but in 1860, they were not. And his slave owner, he did not own any people anymore. He had no more enslaved people. And that's because in Kentucky, the winds of the Second Great Awakening swept through. And I'm told, like, nearly half, if not half, of the slaveholders in Kentucky set their people free as a result of the Second Great Awakening. So, you know, that evangelicalism has a beautiful and powerful birth story here in the US, in the black church, and repercussions that came from it, and power and courage and organizing that came from it in order to get our society clean in the 19th century. But like I said, that's a different strain than what came up in the 20th century. In the 20th century, evangelicalism came up through fundamentalism, which is not the same thing, has a different origin story, but called itself evangelicalism. And I think we all see where it got us. It's gotten us right back. It's basically trying desperately to revive slaveholder faith.
SPEAKER_04Well, say that again and talk more about that. When you said it, it just clicked. Yes. That's what this is.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, that's what it is. So it's that, like, okay, it's not hard at all to draw the line. Right. And the reason why I said it was a mixed bag, even in the 19th century, is because not all evangelicals in the 19th century were like Charles Finney. Like they didn't all get it. And in fact, literally at the same time that Charles Finney was developing this altar call and doing these mass revivals, mostly in the north and in the northern south. You actually had characters like Pastor Richard Furman, the pastor of the first Baptist Church of Charleston, South Carolina. And at that time, there was no such thing as the Southern Baptist Convention. This is 1822, 21. And Denmark, BC attempted one of what would have been one of the largest insurrections in the South. I mean, he had like a thousand people that were signed up to do this thing, but he was ratted out by a fellow enslaved person. And so he and his like core leaders were all captured and beheaded, and their heads were put on spikes around the area. And the thing is, there had been, up to that point, there had already been like a thousand attempted insurrections throughout the South and the North, actually, going back into the 1700s when the North also enslaved people. And so the people in the South and the sentiment around South Carolina circa 1821, when Denmark BC rises up, is maybe we should phase this out. Like they're literally thinking, this is dangerous. Maybe we should actually, you know, incrementally get rid of this thing called slavery. That was the white sentiment in South Carolina, a state that began as a colony that was expressly created for slavery, right? South Carolina was created to enslave people for slavecracy. And people in that state were saying maybe we should phase this out. But no, Richard Furman said, no, we cannot phase this out. We have to clamp down. We have to, we have to get more heinous to our enslaved people. So he actually lobbied and he got a lot of the pastors in the area in South Carolina to lobby the governor of South Carolina to create more stringent slave laws. And so the slave codes were invented and they became much more stringent. And only about 20 years later, the Southern Baptist Convention as a denomination was born. But it was Richard Furman that actually headed up the very first literal convention of Southern Baptists circa 1821. And he fired them up to help to make them protect and entrench the institution of slavery. And of course, we know the story of the Southern Baptist Convention. It started as a convention, a denomination, because the Northern Baptists would not let them be missionaries if they owned slaves. And so they said, we're out. We want to own slaves. And so we're going to do it anyway. That was like 20 years after Furman. Furman's theological exegesis of enslavement in scripture and his theological justification for slavery and slaveocracy became the number one theological foundation that was heralded during the Jim Crow era. So it's like Furman's thinking, you can see it in MAGA right now. That's the through line. It's literally, literally slaveholder faith. And that's the Southern Baptist Convention. That's the largest evangelical denomination in America.
SPEAKER_04I really appreciate you going through this story because, you know, I and a lot of people that I know who have gone to, you know, non-denominational churches in the United States, right? And then later found out, like, yeah, it has Southern Baptist roots or, you know, it's part of the SBC. Like a lot of people don't know the history of like the affiliations, the inner workings of your average, you know, church in their city right now. They're like, oh, I'm looking for a church. Then they go see a big church. A lot of people go to it, their friends go to it. Oh, they like the worship. Yeah. They like the worship. It looks, you know, it looks nice, you know, good childcare, you know, all the fun things, right? Usually great singers, definitely. And really friendly, you know, right. And then if you really are in this space and you start learning how many of these current American modern churches who are non-denominational, right? Have ties to the SBC.
SPEAKER_06PCA too. So now here's the thing to understand is that every single denomination in America split along the lines of for slavery against slavery in the time of the Civil War, or just before it, in the 10 years before it. Well, even really like a couple of decades before. So you basically in the early 1800s, every denomination split along those lines. And so the Southern Baptists just, you know, they went out loud and proud. But, you know, the PCA as a denomination exists as a way to preserve not slaveocracy. I mean, you could say that uh, you know, you can make that analogy, but Jim Crow, right? So they literally formed as a direct response to the civil rights movement and desegregation. So that denomination, it's a southern-based denomination, it has its roots, slaveocracy, um, and absolutely the protection of segregation and um Jim Crow. So, yeah, you have to be aware of where you are. And when they say they're not denominational, you have to ask, what mother church did you come out of? What's the intellectual heritage of this space? It makes a huge difference because the intellectual heritage has implanted, it's like planted seeds of assumptions, of the ways that we read the text, the ways that church works, even like who can be a pastor? Even if it's like official that women can be a pastor, are you going to be considered? I mean, is that even an option? Really, in practice, is it part of the DNA of this church? Is patriarchy a hard part of the DNA of this church? There's this moment during Holy Week, right after Jesus does the Matthew 25 sermon where he separates the sheep from the goats according to how people love the least of these. And this woman bursts into the room and she breaks a jar, an alabaster jar of nard, worth about a year's wages. Now, this woman is dependent on that alabaster jar because that's probably going to be her dowry. And that dowry is the only way that she has some kind of a covering in this patriarchal society where women are dependent on their husbands even to have a roof over their heads. But she breaks that jar and she breaks it because that's how you open it. And once you open it, you can't close it. So she breaks it and then she pours it out over Jesus. And what is the disciples' response? The same people who just listened to that Matthew 25 sermon, they're like, yo, what are you doing? You could have, you could have sold the snard and given the money to the poor. That's a lot of money. Notice how their focus is on the money, on the power of money. Notice how their focus is on the powers that empire says has power. But then notice how her focus is on Jesus, the king of the kingdom of God. Jesus says to them, Why are you rebuking her? Wherever the gospel is told, her story will be told. And this is why I think that's true. Because the gospel, the good news, is about the confrontation of the king of the kingdom of God against the powers of the kingdoms of this world that are hell-bent on crushing the image of God. And she got it right. She said the powers that the empires depend on are not the powers that we depend on. We depend on Jesus.
SPEAKER_04This is so important right now because there is so much power in these churches, right? Like I think that's what we have to understand. And therefore, it is important for those of us who are Christians to make more conscious, empowered choices about the churches we are attending, the churches that we are funding, and the belief systems behind those, right?
SPEAKER_06Your original question to me was, you know, do we need to defend evangelicalism, right? So I'll go back to that because I do want to answer that. I don't think so. I love and I've recounted the history of evangelicalism. I think it's rich. I think it's a mixed bag. I think God has used strains of the evangelical faith to do great, great things, like to create great advances in freedom around the world. And there have been other strains that are corrupted that have also been used to create great, great misery among and for the image of God around the world. And so I don't think that evangelicalism, like any man-made thing, is sacred. I think God is sacred. I think Jesus is sacred. I think the Holy Spirit is sacred. I think the scripture is sacred. I think baptism is sacred. I think the elements, the sacraments are sacred, I think all the rest, God will do what God will do. God even said to like the promised, you know, the chosen people, the Israelites, back in Scripture, you know, you'll be my people, I'll be your God, if, big if, if you follow my ways. You follow my ways, I'm with you. You don't, you know, as Jesus said, it'll be better for you to have an anvil thrown around your neck. I'm mixing metaphors here, but than to let some of the little ones falter here. So if we as a as a faith, a stream of faith, the evangelicals, have not followed God, you know, there's no promise that God is going to preserve the evangelicals. The word evangelical isn't even in scripture. Jesus was not an evangelical.
SPEAKER_04Oh, I love it. That's so true.
SPEAKER_06God is not an evangelical, Jesus was not an evangelical. Not even Charles Finney considered himself an evangelical. Like that term is literally applied to him by a church historian operating in the late 20th century. So that's it's just it's a sociological construct that we created to understand a movement of the Holy Spirit. What we need is a move of the Holy Spirit, not a label.
SPEAKER_04Thank you for that. Um that's incredibly helpful. This is amazing. And as you see, I'd love to geek out together with you. So this is great. Um, my grandparents were missionaries in Asia for 40 years. So that like all this inner work, I get it. I was raised in this fundamentalism stuff. And that's why this is so hard because I see the inside and I see people that really, really believe that if you are outside of it, you are outside of God.
SPEAKER_06Oh, yeah. No, and actually, let me say that is critical to fundamentalism. I mean, fundamentalism in every faith. Whenever you have fundamentalist Muslims or fundamentalist Jews or fundamentalist Christians, fundamentalist Buddhists, if there is such a thing. What it means to be fundamentalist is to believe in an in-group and an out-group. And um, you know, for a fundamentalist, we have the truth and you need the truth in order to be well, like we are well. But that's just not, it literally is just not scripture. Jesus was not a fundamentalist. And he shows us that again and again when he walks through the fields and he picks wheat on the Sabbath, and the Pharisees come up to him who were kind of fundamentalists, and they said, you know, wait, you're breaking the law, you know, you're picking wheat on the Sabbath. And he says, the Sabbath was made to serve humans, not humans to serve the Sabbath, right? Like he was not a fundamentalist. He was about love. Period.
SPEAKER_04Well, then I guess the last question on this one, Lisa, because this is so important for so many folks. For those of us who grew up in fundamentalism who who uh had the misfortune to have our brains wired in that way, a lot of people I've noticed continue that binary. You know, we were told you're either all in or you're out, right? And so we see I see so many former, you know, fundamentalist evangelical white Christians who are atheists now, you know, and a lot of it's because they were kicked out and some of them really have done the work to get there. But a lot of them like are just in this framework of believing this binary and not knowing that there's anything else in the spiritual world in between. So could you just speak to that a little bit for these folks who are just carrying so much grief because they saw the corruption, they left their church spaces, and they are continuously shamed by their family, friends, and community saying, You're backsliding, you're down a slippery slope, you're sinning, you're choosing for yourself. Why did your faith leave you? All these things. And that unspoken grief is there. Yeah. A few years back, back when there was a Twitter. Remember when there was a Twitter? I mean, I used to work there, yes. Oh, yeah, that's oh, that's right. Oh my god. In San Francisco during the Arab Springtime, during the good time. Wow. And now I'm not on it. So we'll geek out over that. But yeah, we can definitely, there's lots to say there. Yeah, it's not Twitter so bad. I missed it so much. I know. I'm not on it. Yeah. They ruined my company.
SPEAKER_06Yep. Ugh. I mean, I lost, I lost so much when it was was bought out. Um, I had spent so much time building up my followership there. And it's like, ah, and I had left. I was like, I'm out. Like, yeah. Anyway, um it back when there was a Twitter. Yeah, yeah. Back when there was one, um, there was uh there was this moment right around the time actually, I think, of the of the spring. Um uh and it was this moment where a lot of people were deconstructing, and I was doing a lot of work on Twitter. I was like, you know, lots of communication through memes and you know, little soundbite kind of things. And I got into it back and forth with this group of white deconstructionists who were talking about how they needed to, you know, basically throw baby Jesus out with the bathwater, like throw the baby out with the bathwater. And I told them, I was like, you realize, right? If you throw out Jesus, if you say, uh, you know, I'm not down with this Jesus, with this Christian thing because they're racist, because that was the main reason why they were saying they're racist, which let's be real, many of them are, then you are actually just showing you have been captured by white supremacy and you you are white supremacist. Because you have to understand that this faith that you are ditching because of white people's racism was not a white faith. It actually is a faith born in Afro-Asia, the Levant. Um it is a people group who, in fact, um just recently I had I did a podcast with Christina Cleveland, who has a really great book out now called The Black Madonna. And so she's looked at, you know, the images of Mary like forevermore, like from the beginning to now, and she confirmed that all of the images of all of the people in scripture, for the first 300 years of Christian faith, they were all black and brown. Wow, all of the images of Jesus and Mary and Paul and Peter, all of the images until Constantine were black and brown. So this is not a white faith. It's a black and brown, indigenous, colonized, serially enslaved faith.
SPEAKER_05I changed me. It changed me. Just seeing a black Madonna for the first time, I was like, oh, I am sacred. My blackness and my femininity is sacred. Her black body is a gospel.
SPEAKER_07Yes, it's true.
SPEAKER_05I'm saying we will be the founders of a new nowhere.
SPEAKER_06We are about to come into a new America. We are not black and brown folks. And women and not to what we had. Because we will pull the patriarchs back to what we otherwise. Because what we had got us to where we are in the colonial structure.
SPEAKER_05We just won't. We're not going to do it. How people are going to be able to do it. In this clearing of a moment. All the places where I was architecting. I was even exposed to a new way.
SPEAKER_06Being together in the world.
SPEAKER_05Do you hear me? Talk to me in the chat if you hear Catholic adjacent. Do you hear what I'm saying?
SPEAKER_06We have the opportunity to be like Catholics.
SPEAKER_05We're worse than everybody else. Because they were American. We can't do that on this side.
SPEAKER_06The front getting out is Catholics. Everybody has to play a part. Are you going to be dealing with the law? Are you going to be, you know, dealing with the voter registration? Get out, the freedom summary that's necessary. Are you the person to organize that? Whatever you are doing for her is what I was saying. Whatever you are doing, you have to live for the story.
SPEAKER_05It's almost always at a desperate new American. It's essentially a dark night of the soul, right? Like what's been working for me is no longer working for me. I and I'm open enough, I'm desperate enough to try something else. And um for me, it happened in the wake of Trump's first.
SPEAKER_06And so when you throw out that baby with the bathwater, saying I'm not going to be Christian because I don't want to be racist or Christian equals racist. Yeah, no, no. You're just responding out of your own white supremacy because if you did one iota of work, you would find, or you would actually even just be able to think about it, these people were brown and they were colonized at the time. Maybe what they had to say, maybe what Jesus had to say, maybe even what Paul even had to say was not going to be something that would further entrench their enslavement, further entrenched, entrenched their colonized status. You know, when you look just an inch deep at even Acts 2. Acts 2, right? This is the moment when the Holy Spirit is pushed out on the world, like it, you know, the tongues of fire. What has the white church done with that? The white church made it about you know, glossophalia, I don't even know how to how to say it, but like, you know, like uh shut up a Honda, Shadow Bada Honda, you know, they're gonna just like all that. And instead, it's not that, it's actually literally not the tongues of angels. That's not what happened in Acts 2. In Acts 2, they spoke each other's languages. Now, what are those languages? I did a little work on this. Every single one of the people groups that the writer of Acts, who many believe is Luke, like listed. When they you you list them, you're that specific. It means something. He actually is trying to communicate something. Every last one of those people groups was colonized by Rome. They're all colonized people. The people who were in the public square speaking in the tongues, they were all colonized people whose languages had been colonized, whose languages they were not able to speak in the public square. There was only one language that was allowed in the public square, Greek. The language of empire. But the Holy Spirit's first act is to lose the tongues of the colonized. It's the first act. But what did the white church do with that moment? Right? They made it this hyper-spiritual moment that you know nobody will really be able to discern. Nobody will it just ooh, look at the spirit causing these people to speak gibberish. They were not speaking gibberish, they understood each other and were speaking each other's. It's it's more radical, it's even more radical than the people suddenly speaking their own colonized language. It was everybody speaking each other's colonized languages, so it was radical connection, radical freedom. I cannot emphasize this enough. So I am not a deconstructionist, I'm not down with that. Because when people who have not confronted, interrogated their own belief in the supremacy of whiteness and westernness, when they approach the scripture with their sensibility, their undecolonized, right? Their colonized sensibility of this brown, serially enslaved, colonized text, then they are really just enacting supremacy over black and brown people once again, determining what of what they said should go and should stay. And they're doing it with a center point in their own being that they have not interrogated that does still believe in the supremacy of whiteness. Wow. So no, I'm not for deconstructing, I'm for decolonizing.
SPEAKER_01Amen.
SPEAKER_04Oh my goodness. Um what I can say now is that when my friend Dr. Mird, who came up to you when the storm happened when we were just in Wild Goose. So funny. She's an episcopal lay priest, has indigenous heritage. Yeah. And she had seen you at Evolving Faith. And I can now, I can feel in my soul what she was feeling about the gifts the Holy Spirit uh speaks through you and through your work. And I am forever grateful that you continue to do this very important work and challenge people. We all need to continue to grow and to learn and to listen no matter where we are on this journey. So I'm gonna have to have you on another time because I want to come back. Bring me back. I'd love to. Okay, great. And we will go through the rest of the document. We didn't even get through the intro. I love it so much. It was just too interesting. All right. So, Lisa Sharon Harper, if there is one thing you could leave everyone around the world with in this very tumultuous time who are struggling with their faith, who are struggling with what to do next, what would you say? Seek brown Jesus. Lisa Sharon Harper, thank you so much for being on the Sacred Slope today.
SPEAKER_06Thank you, Alexis.
SPEAKER_04Oh, thank you so much for being here. What an extraordinary conversation. I am in such admiration of Lisa Sharon Harper, her faith, her knowledge, her wisdom. The way she continues to challenge us to look more deeply at the stories we've inherited about Christianity, race, power, and one another. I know that there's something from this conversation that you are going to carry with you. All right, before you go, I have something I'm so excited to finally tell you about. Some of you listening have participated in the Sacred Slope Pastors Labs that I've hosted together with Reverend Gerlin Henry, Pastor Paul Drees, and Pastor Joe Smith. They have been amazing so far. And ever since we started them, people have been asking me, can you please do this for the rest of us? Here we go. Pastor Joe Smith and I are launching a brand new Sacred Slope Lab series in October and November. And this one is open to everyone, everywhere in the world. This conversation with Lisa is actually the perfect doorway into it because there are three labs. This first is October, 22nd and 23rd. There's two options for each lab. It's called I Thought This Was Christianity. We're going to look at the faith so many of us inherited and ask, what were we taught? Why did it feel so unquestionably Christian? What happens when we discover that what we thought was simply Christianity was actually just one expression within this global diverse, inclusive, ancient faith. We're going to introduce you to the 10 fingers framework and start exploring just how diverse Christianity is. Lab two is November 5th and 6th. Who formed us? This is a question that I cannot stop thinking about. Who is pastoring you on the phone? We are going to look at how faith, fear, belonging, algorithms, media politics, and Christian cultures can work together to form an entire worldview that can go unchallenged. We're going to talk about Christian nationalism, immigration, abortion, LGBTQ issues, gender, patriarchy, race, Christian media and influencers, and how we care for people when the world they thought was certain begins to unravel. And importantly, we're going to talk about reconstruction, not only what we're leaving behind, but what we're building. Lab three is November 12th and 13th. It's speaking across the faith divide. This one is about translators. If you've been wondering about what's going on within Christian nationalism, if you're a journalist, if you're in the media, if you're in politics, your civic leaders, your clergy around the world, who you're like, what is going on over there with that insane, insane conservative evangelicalism and the MAGA world that it has morphed into. How do we talk to people across these divides? So you can attend one, two, or all three labs. You will receive the recording with a registration. And again, these are open to everyone anywhere in the world. And because you're one of the people who stayed with me all the way to the end of the show, I'm giving you a little gift. Our first guest speaker for the October lab is Lisa Sharon Harper. Yes, I'm so excited. I can't wait for you to be able to come and interact with her and ask questions. So you can register at thesacred slope.com. That's my new website. Take a look around because I just launched it. And we've taken these conversations that I've had around a hundred conversations now in the last year and a half with pastors and theologians, scholars, artists, celebrities, and advocates from around the world and broken them into thousands of searchable clips. So if you're studying Christian nationalism, women in ministry, LGBTQ plus inclusion, deconstruction, immigration, scripture, different denominations, you're trying to understand how Christians around the world might be thinking about something like faith and science, you can search by topic or by guest and start exploring. My hope is that this becomes a real resource for seminaries, for curious people, for pastors and churches, for students and anyone trying to expand their understanding of this incredibly diverse faith. And if you'd like to stay connected between episodes, go ahead and join me on the socials and on Substack. That's where I write about faith, travel, Christianity, and whatever I can't stop thinking about that week. We're really building a beautiful community there that's full of pastors from all around the world that are outside of fundamentalism. Last thing, the Sacred Slope is still independently produced by yours truly. I'm funding this work myself. And right now, the expenses are more than the donations that I take in. So, you know, I'm doing all the research, the booking, the social media, the recording, the producing, the publishing, and building all behind it. And I love, love this work. I spend around 40 to 60 hours a week on this work. And I believe deeply that this is helping so many of you out there. If this work means something to you and you are in a position to support it financially, sponsor, or invest in what I'm building here, or if you have serious production or social media expertise and want to be part of its future, please reach out through Alexis at thesacredslope.com. And if that's not something you can do, you can help enormously by subscribing, reviewing, or sending this episode to someone who needs to hear it. Every one of those things matters. Let's keep building this together. Don't forget to vote in midterms. And thank you so much for being part of this community. I'll leave you with the same thing that I tell my daughters every morning before they go to school. Make sure you find an opportunity to be kind today. I'm Alexis Rice. Go in peace, friends. Oh, and if you like this content, make sure to follow the Sacred Slope on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, Threads, TikTok, and Blue Sky at the Sacred Slope. You can watch on YouTube or Spotify, and you can listen on Apple and everywhere you get your podcasts.
SPEAKER_07Until next time.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The New Evangelicals Podcast
Hosted by Tim Whitaker
The Tim & April Show
The New Evangelicals
Data Over Dogma
Daniel McClellan and Daniel Beecher
Recovering Evangelicals
Luke Jeffrey Janssen
The Holy Post
Phil Vischer
Pivot
New York Magazine
The Curiosity Shop with Brené Brown and Adam Grant
Vox Media Podcast Network
Unlocking Us with Brené Brown
Vox Media Podcast Network
The Bible For Normal People
Peter Enns and Jared Byas
And Also With You
The Reverend Lizzie McManus-Dail, The Reverend Laura Di Panfilo
Reclaiming My Theology
Brandi Miller
Holy Heretics: Losing Religion and Finding Jesus
The Sophia Society
Learning How to See with Brian McLaren
Center for Action and Contemplation
VeggieTales: Very Veggie Silly Stories
Big Idea Entertainment
The Evolving Faith Podcast
Evolving Faith
Another Name For Every Thing with Richard Rohr
Center for Action and Contemplation
Religion on the Mind
Dan Koch
The Ezra Klein Show
New York Times Opinion
Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov
Vox Media Podcast Network